Data from: Female ornamentation is correlated with weather conditions during molt in Protonotaria citrea (Prothonotary Warblers): A 13-year study
Data files
Jul 03, 2025 version files 463.76 KB
-
breast_feathers.csv
234.19 KB
-
crown_feathers.csv
219.22 KB
-
README.md
10.34 KB
Abstract
Avian species have inspired numerous studies on ornamentation, exploring its role in intra- and intersexual selection as a marker for individual quality. Male birds have been the focus of most studies of plumage coloration, even though females can also display ornamentation. Coloration added to feathers during their growth, particularly carotenoid-based pigments, is derived from food resources. As weather patterns affect food availability and abundance, there may be a link between weather conditions during molt and feather coloration in the subsequent breeding season. We collected 474 breast feather samples from 329 unique female Protonotaria citrea (Prothonotary Warbler) and 436 crown feather samples from 310 females across 13 years (2010-2023) in eastern Virginia, USA, to assess relationships between temperature and precipitation during molt and breast and crown feather reflectance metrics the following year. We considered conditions in both the breeding and nonbreeding seasons as possible drivers of crown reflectance because at least some feathers are replaced during a previously undescribed limited prealternate molt. Breast and crown violet-blue chroma was lower, and breast yellow intensity was higher following cooler and wetter conditions during the late summer molt and not the winter prealternate molt. The negative impact of warmer temperatures on breast yellow intensity was greater in younger females. These results provide insight into how climate conditions affect female plumage coloration, which has previously been linked to reproductive success, and may aid in understanding the impacts of climate change on carotenoids as honest signals of individual condition.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.3xsj3txtc
Description of the data and file structure
This data includes 474 breast feather samples from 329 unique female Protonotaria citrea (Prothonotary Warbler) and 436 crown feather samples from 310 females across 13 years (2010-2023) in eastern Virginia, USA to assess relationships between temperature and precipitation during molt and breast and crown feather reflectance metrics the following year. Feathers were mounted on black cardstock then measured with an Ocean Optics JazPX spectrometer with a DET2B-UV detector (Ocean Optics, Dunedin, Florida, USA) sensitive to light in the 300–800 nm range, for both the visible (400–750 nm) and UV (320–400 nm) spectra. Weather data was determined from the Richmond International Airport, Virginia, USA and NOAA STAR mean vegetation condition index.
Files and variables
File: breast_feathers.csv
Description: Contains morphological data for individual female birds including feather reflectance values for breast feathers, age, sex, etc. Also contains temperature and precipitation values for central Virginia, USA. Missing values are indicated by "NA."
Variables
- BandNumber: The ID of the sampled individual
- B2: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "mean brightness."
- S1U: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "ultraviolet chroma," the relative contribution of UV to total brightness
- S1B: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "violet-blue chroma," calculated by the sum of reflectance in the violet-blue region divided by the sum of total reflectance in the entire spectrum
- S9: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "carotenoid chroma," the relative contribution of blue light to total brightness
- YelInt: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "yellow intensity," calculated by the average reflectance in the yellow region minus the minimum reflectance in the blue region
- Year: The year at which the individual bird was sampled
- Date: The exact date (YYYY-MM-DD) at which the individual bird was sampled
- Site: The location the individual bird was sampled
- Box: The nest box the individual bird was sampled at
- Sex: The sex of the bird marked as female (F)
- Age: The age of the bird marked as ASY (after second-year) or SY (second-year)
- yrs_breeding: The number of years the bird has been a breeding adult
- Weight: The weight of the bird in grams
- DateHatchedEstimated: The date of when the individual bird was hatched
- LastHatchDate: The date of when the bird last hatched a nest in a given season
- LastHatchDate_prev: The ordinal day of when the bird last hatched a nest the previous season (relative to "Year")
- LagYear: "Year" - 1 or, in other words, the year before the bird was sampled
- Mean_Temp_7: The mean temperature of July (degrees Celsius)
- Mean_Temp_8: The mean temperature of August (degrees Celsius)
- Max_Temp_7: The maximum temperature of July (degrees Celsius)
- Max_Temp_8: The maximum temperature of August (degrees Celsius)
- Min_Temp_7: The minimum temperature of July (degrees Celsius)
- Min_Temp_8: The minimum temperature of August (degrees Celsius)
- Extreme_Temp_7: If the temperature departure of July greater than one standard deviation of temperature departure, then it is assigned a 1. If less, then it is assigned a 0
- Extreme_Temp_8: If the temperature departure of August is greater than one standard deviation of temperature departure, then it is assigned a 1. If less, then it is assigned a 0
- Temp_Anomaly_7: The mean of the average temperature departure in July (degrees Celsius)
- Temp_Anomaly_8: The mean of the average temperature departure in August (degrees Celsius)
- Mean_Prcp_7: The mean precipitation of July (inches)
- Mean_Prcp_8: The mean precipitation of August (inches)
- Max_Prcp_7: The maximum precipitation of July (inches)
- Max_Prcp_8: The maximum precipitation of August (inches)
- Sum_Prcp_7: The total precipitation in July (inches)
- Sum_Prcp_8: The total precipitation in August (inches)
- Prcp_Anomaly_7: The mean of the precipitation departure in July (inches)
- Prcp_Anomaly_8: The mean of the precipitation departure in August (inches)
- Mean_Temp_78: The mean summer (July & August) temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Max_Temp_78: The maximum summer (July & August) temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Min_Temp_78: The minimum summer (July & August) temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Extreme_Temp_78: If the summer (July & August) temperature departure is greater than one standard deviation of temperature departure, then it is assigned a 1. If less, then it is assigned a 0
- Temp_Anomaly_78: The mean of the average summer (July & August) temperature departure (degrees Celsius)
- Mean_Prcp_78: The mean summer (July & August) precipitation (inches)
- Max_Prcp_78: The maximum summer (July & August) precipitation (inches)
- Sum_Prcp_78: The total summer (July & August) precipitation (inches)
- Prcp_Anomaly_78: The mean of the summer (July & August) precipitation departure (inches)
File: crown_feathers.csv
Description: Contains morphological data for individual female birds including feather reflectance values for crown feathers, age, sex, etc. Also contains temperature and precipitation values for central Virginia, USA and the mean vegetation condition index for regions in Colombia. Missing values are indicated by "NA."
Variables
- BandNumber: The ID of the sampled individual
- B2: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "mean brightness."
- S1U: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "ultraviolet chroma," the relative contribution of UV to total brightness
- S1B: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "violet-blue chroma," calculated by the sum of reflectance in the violet-blue region divided by the sum of total reflectance in the entire spectrum
- S9: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "carotenoid chroma," the relative contribution of blue light to total brightness
- YelInt2: Feather reflectance metric corresponding to "yellow intensity," calculated by the average reflectance in the yellow region minus the minimum reflectance in the blue region
- Year: The year at which the individual bird was sampled
- Date: The exact date (YYYY-MM-DD) at which the individual bird was sampled
- Site: The location the individual bird was sampled
- Box: The nest box the individual bird was sampled at
- Sex: The sex of the bird marked as female (F)
- Age: The age of the bird marked as ASY (after second-year) or SY (second-year)
- yrs_breeding: The number of years the bird has been a breeding adult
- Weight: The weight of the bird in grams
- DateHatchedEstimated: The date of when the individual bird was hatched
- LastHatchDate: The date of when the bird last hatched a nest in a given season
- LastHatchDate_prev: The ordinal day of when the bird last hatched a nest the previous season (relative to "Year")
- LagYear: "Year" - 1 or, in other words, the year before the bird was sampled
- Mean_Temp_7: The mean temperature of July (degrees Celsius)
- Mean_Temp_8: The mean temperature of August (degrees Celsius)
- Max_Temp_7: The maximum temperature of July (degrees Celsius)
- Max_Temp_8: The maximum temperature of August (degrees Celsius)
- Min_Temp_7: The minimum temperature of July (degrees Celsius)
- Min_Temp_8: The minimum temperature of August (degrees Celsius)
- Extreme_Temp_7: If the temperature departure of July greater than one standard deviation of temperature departure, then it is assigned a 1. If less, then it is assigned a 0
- Extreme_Temp_8: If the temperature departure of August is greater than one standard deviation of temperature departure, then it is assigned a 1. If less, then it is assigned a 0
- Temp_Anomaly_7: The mean of the average temperature departure in July (degrees Celsius)
- Temp_Anomaly_8: The mean of the average temperature departure in August (degrees Celsius)
- Mean_Prcp_7: The mean precipitation of July (inches)
- Mean_Prcp_8: The mean precipitation of August (inches)
- Max_Prcp_7: The maximum precipitation of July (inches)
- Max_Prcp_8: The maximum precipitation of August (inches)
- Sum_Prcp_7: The total precipitation in July (inches)
- Sum_Prcp_8: The total precipitation in August (inches)
- Prcp_Anomaly_7: The mean of the precipitation departure in July (inches)
- Prcp_Anomaly_8: The mean of the precipitation departure in August (inches)
- Mean_Temp_78: The mean summer (July & August) temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Max_Temp_78: The maximum summer (July & August) temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Min_Temp_78: The minimum summer (July & August) temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Extreme_Temp_78: If the summer (July & August) temperature departure is greater than one standard deviation of temperature departure, then it is assigned a 1. If less, then it is assigned a 0
- Temp_Anomaly_78: The mean of the average summer (July & August) temperature departure (degrees Celsius)
- Mean_Prcp_78: The mean summer (July & August) precipitation (inches)
- Max_Prcp_78: The maximum summer (July & August) precipitation (inches)
- Sum_Prcp_78: The total summer (July & August) precipitation (inches)
- Prcp_Anomaly_78: The mean of the summer (July & August) precipitation departure (inches)
- meanvci: Weather metric corresponding to the mean vegetation condition index (VCI) of multiple regions in Colombia. VCI is a measure of drought or "greenness"
Code/software
R version 4.3.2 was used to view and analyze this data.
Access information
Weather data was derived from the following sources:
- U.S. Department of Commerce, National Oceanic & Atmospheric Administration, & National Environmental Satellite, Data, and Information Service. (2004). Annual climatology: Richmond, VA (RIC). National Drought Mitigation Center. https://drought.unl.edu/archive/climographs/RichmondANC.htm
- NOAA / NESDIS Center for Satellite Applications and Research. (2019). STAR - Global Vegetation Health Products. https://www.star.nesdis.noaa.gov/smcd/emb/vci/VH/VH Syst_10ap30.php
