Forward steps, lingering gaps: Gender representation among distinguished speakers at professional conferences
Data files
Apr 28, 2025 version files 107.55 KB
-
DistinguishedSpeakerDataSheet_Combined_Studies_for_Dryad.xlsx
104.75 KB
-
README.md
2.80 KB
Abstract
Professional conferences are an ideal venue for assessing progress towards equity goals within and across disciplines. We examined gender disparities among distinguished speakers at North American ecology conferences from 2000 to 2023. Women's representation has increased, especially in the past decade, but they remain underrepresented relative to their proportion among graduate students. Disparities persist across institutions, disciplines, and career stages, particularly for late-career women. Additionally, the COVID pandemic did not notably impact the representation of women in these roles, and non-binary genders remain minimally represented, underscoring ongoing challenges in achieving inclusive representation. While the gap has not yet closed and the number of non-binary speakers is vanishingly small, the emerging positive trend for women speakers is encouraging. Plenary speakers serve as role models for early-career scholars, and giving these talks advances their careers and celebrates the important scientific contributions women are making at high levels in their field.
https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.b8gtht7nj
Description of the data and file structure
Data are entered in an Excel spreadsheet. Column heading categories and descriptions are listed in Table 1. Entries of n/a indicate that data were not available, or in the case of Speaker Field of Expertise 2, a 2nd field of expertise was not applicable to that speaker.
Table 1. Summary of categories of data collected for distinguished speakers invited to speak at professional conferences in ecology from 2000-2023.
| Society(ies) | The society that the conference was associated with |
|---|---|
| Conference | The conference name |
| Year | 2000-2023 |
| Attendance Type | In-person; virtual; hybrid |
| Career Stage | Early; Mid; Late |
| Speaker Field Expertise 1 and 2 | The first and second fields of expertise listed in the speaker's bio. |
| Field Expertise Simplified | The speaker’s field of expertise simplified into one of the following categories: Arts and Humanities, Life and Physical Sciences, Policy, Social Sciences |
| Talk Type | Award Recipient; Keynote; Moderator/Panelist; Plenary |
| Institution Type | Academia; Government; Private Sector; Museums/Zoos/Aquaria/NGOs |
| Pronouns | She/her; He/him (only 1 speaker used they/them pronouns and they were removed from the dataset to protect anonymity). |
To assess gender representation among distinguished speakers, we followed the methods outlined in Farr et al. (2017). We defined distinguished speakers as plenary and keynote speakers, award recipients, and panelists (hereafter distinguished speakers). We collected information on distinguished speakers from the same list of conferences listed in (Farr et al. 2017), with the exception of a new conference hosted by the Society for Urban Ecology. All conferences on the list took place in North America between 2000-2015 (Farr et al. 2017) and 2016-2023 for the new dataset. We collected the following data for each conference: the society hosting the conference; conference title, subfield, and year; whether the conference was in-person, virtual, or hybrid; speaker names, titles, career stage, field of expertise, and pronouns; what type of talk the speaker gave (i.e., award recipient, keynote, panelist or moderator, or plenary); the speaker’s organization; and the type of institution with which the speaker was affiliated. We collected pronouns for each speaker from their speaker biography. In this manuscript, we refer to speakers with she/her pronouns as women, those with he/him pronouns as men, and speakers with they/them pronouns as gender non-binary. The number of speakers identifying as non-binary (n=1) was extremely limited; thus, we were unable to include non-binary speakers in our statistical analyses.
