Osmia lignaria larval development response to heatwave treatments
Data files
Mar 11, 2024 version files 40.31 KB
-
heatwave_emergence.csv
19.62 KB
-
heatwave_nov.csv
16.48 KB
-
README.md
4.21 KB
Abstract
Heatwaves are expected to increase in frequency, intensity, and duration due to climate change. For organisms like insects with discrete development, sensitivity may differ among life stages. Thermal sensitivity is of particular concern for species like bees that provide critical ecosystem services. Although social bees moderate nest temperatures through worker behavior, solitary bees do not thermoregulate their nests, making immobile developing offspring especially vulnerable to such extreme events.
We studied the effects of heatwaves on larval development in the solitary bee, Osmia lignaria, an important orchard pollinator and model species for solitary bee biology. We used a factorial design to assess the impacts of heatwave temperature and duration on larval mortality and development rate. Larvae were exposed to heatwaves under realistic diel temperature regimes, with daytime maxima of 31˚C or 37˚C for four or seven days at the beginning of development.
Heatwave temperature strongly affected larval mortality. Exposure to 37˚C heatwaves increased larval mortality by 130%, but the cooler 31˚C heatwaves did not significantly impact mortality. Heatwave duration did not impact larval mortality.
Larval development time also was affected by heatwave exposure. Compared to the no-heatwave-control, bees in the 31˚C heatwave developed faster, and bees in the 37˚C heatwave developed slower.
Our study reveals the importance of stage-specific effects of extreme events and suggests that the timing and maximum temperature of projected heatwaves may be more detrimental to populations than heatwave duration.
https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.kkwh70sb7
Authors: Grace G. Melone, Clara Stuligross, and Neal M. Williams. University of California, Davis
Description of the data and file structure
See methodology in associated manuscript.
heatwave_nov.csv:
NestNumber: individual nest which contained multiple bees
BeeID: individually marked bee
Treatment: integer value 1-5 indicating heatwave treatment:
- Control
- Low temperature, Short duration
- Low temperature, Long duration
- High temperature, Short duration
- High temperature, Long duration
DurationX: integer value 4 or 7, indicating short or long heatwave duration
TemperatureX: integer value 25, 33, or 37, indicating control, low temperature heatwave, and high temperature heatwave temperatures, respectively. While temperature is marked as 33 in the data, the true temperature as indicated by temperature loggers in incubators was 31.
DateCollected: Month/Day corresponding to the date completed nests were collected for the experiment
Location: character value of NH or SH, corresponding to which hoop house nests were collected from
Position: integer value indicating position in nest, where 1 was the first egg at the end of the nest bees would start from.
EstimatedSex: integer value of 0 or 1 indicating estimated sex, with 0 indicating males and 1 indicating females.
StageOnCollection: larval stage bees were in when nests were collected (0 as all bees used were in the egg stage)
Instar1: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to develop to instar 1
Instar2: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to develop to instar 2
Instar34: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to develop to instar 3 or 4.
Instar5: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to develop to instar 5.
SpinStart: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to begin spinning cocoons.
CocoonComplete: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to completing spinning of the cocoon.
Mortality: integer value of 0 or 1, with 0 indicating bees survived and 1 indicating bees died before reaching the end of prepupal development.
MortalityDate: month/day indicating the date bees died.
DaystoDeath: integer value indicating the number of days from collection to mortality
DeathStage: integer corresponding to larval stage at which bees died:
0. egg
- instar 1
- instar 2
- instar 3
- instar 4
- instar 5
Weight: fresh integer indicating fresh weight of bees in grams which completed cocoons, all bees were weighed in early July 2020
Weight_Sept: integer indicating fresh weight of bees in grams which completed cocoons in September of 2020
Weight_Nov: integer indicating fresh weight of bees in grams which completed cocoons in November of 2020
Notes: notes taken throughout the experiment
heatwave_emergence.csv (includes all of the above data and emergence data, repeated columns not listed below):
mortality_postlarv: integer value of 0 or 1; where 0 indicates survival and 1 indicates mortality
DeathStage: integer value of 0-8; integers 0-5 described above
6. prepupa
7. pupa
8. adult
itd: blank column
weight_feb: integer indicating fresh weight of bees in grams which completed cocoons in February of 2021
emergence: integer value of 0 or 1; where 0 indicates bees did not emerge and 1 indicates successful emergence
emergence_date: mm/dd/yy date that bees emerged from their cocoons
sex: character value of F or M; where F indicates females and M indicates males
Note on NAs/empty cells in the csvs: empty cells indicate no data was recorded for that larva for that day, and have not been modified as to not affect code. After larvae died, no data was entered into the cells that would have contained days to each life stage or weight data.
Sharing/Access information
Links to other publicly accessible locations of the data:
Data was collected by scoring larval development stage and mortality, after bees cocooned we weighed bees until emergence. Emergence date was also recorded.
- Melone, Grace G.; Stuligross, Clara; Williams, Neal M. (2024), Heatwaves increase larval mortality and delay development of a solitary bee, Ecological Entomology, Journal-article, https://doi.org/10.1111/een.13317
