Data from: A framework for sharing power in research teams and promoting justice in scientific publication
Data files
Feb 14, 2025 version files 23.09 KB
-
Cockle_et_al_2025_Sharing_Power_data.csv
21.41 KB
-
README.md
1.68 KB
Abstract
Many ornithologists seek tools to work more equitably with people from historically marginalized and exploited groups. We developed a process to promote collective construction of ornithological knowledge in the special feature "Ecology and conservation of cavity nesters in the Neotropics'' for the journals Ornithology and Ornithological Applications. Colonialism produces systems that consecrate eurocentric ideas from dominant nations (including Canada, USA, and countries of western Europe) and reinforce hierarchies of power between and within regions. Recognizing these systems, we proposed a special feature to support, highlight, and connect teams from Latin America, a region historically exploited by imperial powers. We adopted sociocracy, a governance model that promotes sharing of power, to create the proposal and organize the call for papers and to write a review and this perspective article. We adopted and developed transparent, consent-based decision-making processes, including a process for determining authorship order. We crafted open invitations, used collective proposals (structured brainstorming), encouraged citation of work from regional journals, tested a system for manuscript submission and review in Spanish, and introduced mechanisms for multi-way feedback. This framework helped reduce some barriers commonly faced by historically marginalized authors, distribute power more equitably, and recognize a broader diversity of contributions to ornithology. Despite these efforts, several challenges remained. For example, the publishing interests of Ornithology, Ornithological Applications, and most high impact ornithological journals are often poorly aligned with current research priorities in many parts of Latin America (e.g. reproductive biology of endangered species). We encourage scientists at all career stages, technicians, and non-academics to reflect on their citation politics (which sources they cite, and how their citation practice may unintentionally reproduce inequities), and to implement collective workflows that promote equitable sharing of power within research teams.
https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.stqjq2cd1
Description of the data and file structure
We collected the data to calculate the proportion of authors affiliated in the Neotropics in Special Features of the two journals of the American Ornithological Society, Ornithology and Ornithological Applications.
Files and variables
File: Cockle_et_al_2025_Sharing_Power_data.csv
Description:
Variables
- ID Paper: Article identifier provided by the journal.
- Source: Article version (Published, accepted, page proof, or online early).
- Special Feature Name: Which special feature the article was part of (Advances in Neotropical Ornithology, Advances in Avian Diet Methods and Applications, Species Limits and Taxonomy in Birds, or Ecology and Conservation of Cavity Nesters in the Neotropics.
- Article: Abbreviated authors and topic of article.
- Author order: Author position in author list at top of article.
- Name: Full name of author.
- Any affiliation in Neotropics 1_yes 0_no: Did the author list any affiliation in a country of South America, the Caribbean, or Central America (including Mexico)? NA indicates Not Applicable because the author is a group without a single geographical location.
- First author first affiliation in Neotropics 1_yes 0_no: Did the first author list their first affiliation in a country of South America, the Caribbean, or Central America (including Mexico)? NA indicates Not Applicable because the author in question is not the first author of the paper.
We downloaded all 33 articles included in the three Special Features of American Ornithological Society journals published in 2020–2023 from the following web pages: https://academic.oup.com/aosjournals/pages/advances-in-avian-diet, https://academic.oup.com/aosjournals/pages/species-limits-and-taxonomy, and https://academic.oup.com/aosjournals/pages/advances-in-neotropical-ornithology. We also downloaded all nine articles included in the Special Feature that four of us convened: "Ecology and Conservation of Cavity nesters in the Neotropics" (2024–2025). For each article, we consulted the author list and affiliations, and indicated whether the affiliation was in a country of the Neotropics (South America, Caribbean, and Central America, including all of Mexico).
