Europeans support large carnivore recovery while opposing both further population growth and hunting
Data files
Nov 25, 2025 version files 97.02 KB
-
README.md
4.48 KB
-
survey.Rdata
92.55 KB
Abstract
After centuries of persecution in Europe, large carnivores are now recovering. Whether this conservation success continues likely depends on public support. Here, we show using a survey of ten thousand respondents across European Union Member States that, while support for the recovery of wolves, bears, and lynx remains strong, most respondents oppose both further population growth and hunting—particularly of wolves. Attitudes are remarkably consistent across rural and urban populations, and many respondents express no strong position, suggesting that large carnivores are less polarizing than often portrayed. The recent amendment to the Habitats Directive, which grants Member States greater flexibility to manage their wolf populations, appears broadly aligned with public opinion, as long as its implementation does not lead to population declines. However, the presence of views in tension—rejecting both population growth and hunting— may pose challenges for designing policies that are both science-based and democratic.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.w6m905r2k
Description of the data and file structure
Files and variables
File: survey.Rdata
Description:
Answers from respondents are in the object ‘opinion.data’ in the file ‘survey.Rdata’
Every row is an individual respondent and columns show question answers from this respondent.
head(opinion.data)
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q5 Q6_1 Q6_2 Q6_3 Q7 Q8 Q9 Q10 Q11 Q12 country
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 1 26 2 4 3 3 AT
5 5 5 5 1 1 1 1 1 30 1 3 1 1 AT
3 4 4 4 3 3 2 2 1 42 2 3 2 2 AT
3 3 4 3 3 4 3 3 2 58 1 2 2 1 AT
4 4 4 4 1 4 3 3 2 28 2 4 1 1 AT
3 3 3 3 3 2 2 2 2 43 2 2 3 3 AT
Questions and answers are as follows:
Q1: Large carnivores such as wolves, brown bears and lynx have been recolonizing parts of Europe in recent decades. Generally speaking, would you say that you support or oppose the recovery of large carnivores?
1: Strongly oppose
2: Oppose
3: Neutral or not sure
4: Support
5: Strongly support
Q2: In my opinion, wolf populations in Europe should be…
1: Decreased greatly
2: Decreased
3: Stay about the same
4: Increased
5: Increased greatly
6: I don’t know
Q3: In my opinion, lynx populations in Europe should be…
1: Decreased greatly
2: Decreased
3: Stay about the same
4: Increased
5: Increased greatly
6: I don’t know
Q4: In my opinion, brown bear populations in Europe should be…
1: Decreased greatly
2: Decreased
3: Stay about the same
4: Increased
5: Increased greatly
6: I don’t know
Q5: Generally speaking, would you say that you support or oppose hunting large carnivores?
1: Strongly oppose
2: Oppose
3: Neutral or not sure
4: Support
5: Strongly support
To what extent do you agree or disagree with the following:
Q6_1: If a bear attacks a person, that bear should be killed regardless of the circumstances.
Q6_2: Wolves that kill livestock should be killed.
Q6_3: A lynx that kills livestock should be killed.
1: Strongly disagree
2: Somewhat disagree
3: Neither agree nor disagree
4: Somewhat agree
5: Strongly agree
Q7: What is your sex?
1: Female
2: Male
Q8: Enter the year you were born
in YYYY format (note: data shows respondent's age)
Q9: How would you describe your current residence or community?
1: Isolated house / Village
2: City / Large urban area
Q10: When it comes to politics, please indicate which of the following you consider yourself.
1: Extreme left
2: Left (socio-democrat)
3: Centre
4: Right (conservative)
5: Extreme right
Q11: Below are a number of actions you could take in order to support the conservation of large carnivores in your country. Please indicate how likely or unlikely you are to... Write to or call a politician to express your support for carnivore restoration efforts.
1: Very Unlikely
2: Somewhat Unlikely
3: Undecided
4: Somewhat Likely
5: Very Likely
Q12: Below are a number of actions you could take in order to oppose large carnivore populations in your country. Please indicate how likely or unlikely you are to... write to or call a politician to express your opposition to carnivore restoration efforts.
1: Very Unlikely
2: Somewhat Unlikely
3: Undecided
4: Somewhat Likely
5: Very Likely
country: country where the respondent is from:
AT: Austria
BE: Belgium
BG: Bulgaria
CZ: Czechia
DE: Germany
DK: Denmark
EE: Estonia
ES: Spain
FI: Finland
FR: France
GR: Greece
HR: Croatia
HU: Hungary
IT: Italy
LT: Lithuania
LV: Latvia
NL: Netherlands
PL: Poland
PT: Portugal
RO: Romania
SE: Sweden
SI: Slovenia
SK: Slovakia
Code/software
All analyses were conducted using the R statistical software v. 4.5.0.
Access information
A reproducible analysis based on this dataset is available at https://doi.org/10.24433/CO.3129691.v2
Human subjects data
All participants provided informed consent prior to participation to the survey, and responses were de-identified by Qualtrics before being made available to the research team. The study was GDPR compliant and approved by the Swedish Ethical Review Authority (permit 2022-04276-01).
We conducted an opinion survey between 2022 and 2023 of 10,807 respondents across all 23 European countries that host breeding populations of large carnivores, using the Qualtrics online survey platform. For each surveyed country, we aimed to include at least 500 respondents, with a balanced distribution across key demographic categories: an equal number of female and male participants, equal representation of individuals younger and older than the country-specific median age, and an equal number of respondents from rural and urban areas (self-reported by participants). Respondents were asked a series of questions to assess their attitudes toward large carnivore recovery in Europe, their views on desirable future population trends for wolves, lynx, and brown bears, and their opinions on the hunting and culling of these species. In addition, we collected demographic and political covariates.
