Risk of parasiticides diflubenzuron, eprinomectin, and fenbendazole to dung-associated beetles
Data files
Jul 30, 2025 version files 2.31 MB
-
HPLC_Data.csv
12.25 KB
-
HPLC.pdf
564.80 KB
-
HPLC.xml
62.57 KB
-
JA_DataNoColonizers.csv
55.05 KB
-
Muscid_Bin.pdf
456.11 KB
-
Muscid_Bin.xml
61.92 KB
-
Muscids.csv
42.34 KB
-
Predator_Bin.pdf
495.81 KB
-
Predator_Bin.xml
65.47 KB
-
README.md
3.87 KB
-
Scarab_Bin.pdf
440.82 KB
-
Scarab_Bin.xml
53.01 KB
Abstract
Dung-associated beetles provide crucial ecosystem services, including reducing pasture fouling and contributing to animal and pasture health. However, parasiticides used on cattle can negatively impact beetles. We assessed the exposure and impact of Clarifly ® (active ingredient [a.i.] diflubenzuron), LongRange ® (a.i. eprinomectin), and Safe-guard ® (a.i. fenbendazole) on beetles and flies. Using high-performance liquid chromatography, we quantified the residual concentrations of these chemicals in cattle feces for 150 days. We found fenbendazole excreted within the first 3 days after treatment (DAT), while diflubenzuron and eprinomectin persisted for 8-12 weeks. To estimate the concentrations of these active ingredients that are toxic to beetles, we dosed cattle dung with diflubenzuron, eprinomectin, or fenbendazole, allowed insects to colonize in the field, and monitored the emergence of beetles. Dung beetle (Scarabaeidae) abundance was negatively impacted by diflubenzuron and eprinomectin, while fenbendazole had no negative effects. Predatory beetles, families Carabidae, Histeridae, Hydrophilidae, and Staphylinidae, were unaffected by all chemicals. We found that dung from animals treated with LongRange ® was toxic to Scarabaeidae for 30 to 90 DAT. Similarly, diflubenzuron was toxic to Scarabaeidae when cattle consistently consumed it, although the concentration of diflubenzuron in dung varied when cattle were fed using Clarifly ®. In contrast, the active ingredient in Safe-guard ®, fenbendazole, was not toxic at 10 mg/kg. Although we found this product excreted at higher concentrations for 1 DAT, it likely poses little risk. Our results suggest that producers who value beneficial beetles as a management goal should avoid eprinomectin and diflubenzuron products that excrete for long periods.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.8kprr4z06
Description of the data and file structure
We assessed the exposure and impact of Clarifly® (active ingredient [a.i.] diflubenzuron), LongRange® (a.i. eprinomectin), and Safe-guard® (a.i. fenbendazole) on beetles and flies. Using high-performance liquid chromatography, we quantified the residual concentrations of these chemicals in cattle feces for 150 days.
To estimate the concentrations of these active ingredients that are toxic to beetles, we dosed cattle dung with diflubenzuron, eprinomectin, or fenbendazole, allowed insects to colonize in the field, and monitored the emergence of beetles.
Files and variables
File: HPLC_Data.csv
Description: Contains concentrations of parasiticides diflubenzuron, fenbendazole, eprinomectin, ivermectin and moxidectin from samples in 2022 and 2023. We did not include results from Ivermectin and Moxidectin in final manuscript because of issues with detection.
Variables
- Year:2022 or 2023, when fecal samples were collected
- Treatment:Active ingredient quantified based on available standards
- ID: ID tag number of heifer sampled
- DAT: Day after treatment ranges from 1-150
- Concentration (ppm): Concentration of active ingredient in parts per million
File: JA_DataNoColonizers.csv
Description: Count of animals emerging from dung bins. Dung beetles separated into species, predators and muscids summed without identifying further.
Variables
- Month: Month that emergence bins were placed in the field; either June or August of 2023
- Location: Name of farm where emergence bins were placed
- Treatment: Type of chemical active ingredient used to dose manure pat
- Dosage: Concentration of chemical active ingredient. Concentrations depended on the chemical used, details of which can be found in the manuscript.
- Replication: Replicate number at each site and month
- Block: Bins where arranged in blocks while in the field
- Ataenius striatus – Aphodius psuedolividus: Count of dung beetles per species found in each bin
- DB ID’d by part: Some of the dung beetles were counted based on the presence of thoraxes in the soil.
- Summed_Scarabs: total number of scarabs in previous columns
- Summed_muscids: total number of muscid flies found in each bin
- Summed_predators: total number of predatory beetles, including carabids, staphynilids, histerids, and hydrophylid beetles.
File: Muscids.csv
Description: Count of muscid flies collected from emergence bins
Variables
- Month: Month that emergence bins were placed in the field; either June or August of 2023
- Location: Name of farm where emergence bins were placed
- Treatment: Type of chemical active ingredient used to dose manure pat
- Dosage: Concentration of chemical active ingredient. Concentrations depended on the chemical used, details of which can be found in the manuscript.
- Replication: Replicate number at each site and month
- Block: Bins where arranged in blocks while in the field
- Summed_Muscids: Total muscids caught in each bin.
Files: Predator_Bin.pdf & Predator_Bin.xml
Description: is the analysis of predatory taxa, including rove beetles, carabids, histerids and hydrophylids found in bins from JA_DataNoColonizers.csv
File: HPLC.pdf& HPLC.xml
Description: is the analysis of HPLC_Data.csv, and includes analysis of Eprinomectin, Diflubenzuron, and Fendbendazole, as well as Ivermectin and Moxidectin.
File: Muscid_Bin.pdf & Muscid_Bin.xml
Description: is the analysis of Muscids.csv
File: Scarab_Bin.pdf & Scarab_Bin.xml
Description: R markdown file of the analysis of Scarabeaidae found in emergence bins from JA_DataNoColonizers.csv