Skip to main content
Dryad

Data from: Amino acid δ15N underestimation of cetacean trophic positions highlights poor understanding of isotopic fractionation in higher marine consumers

Data files

Feb 10, 2021 version files 55.97 KB

Abstract

  1. Compound specific stable isotope analysis (CSIA) of amino acids (AAs) has been rapidly incorporated in ecological studies to resolve consumer trophic position (TP). Differential 15N fractionation of ‘trophic’ AAs, which undergo 15N enrichment with each trophic step, and ‘source’ AAs, which undergo minimal trophic 15N enrichment and serve as a proxy for primary producer δ15N values, allows for internal calibration of TP. Recent studies, however, have shown the difference between source and trophic AA δ15N values in higher marine consumers is less than predicted from empirical studies of invertebrates and fish.
  2. To evaluate CSIA-AA for estimating TP of cetaceans, we compared source and trophic AA δ15N values of multiple tissues (skin, baleen, and dentine collagen) from five species representing a range of TPs: bowhead whales, beluga whales, short-beaked common dolphins, sperm whales, and fish-eating (FE) and marine mammal-eating (MME) killer whale ecotypes.
  3. TP estimates (TPCSIA) using several empirically-derived equations and trophic discrimination factors (TDFs) were 1 to 2.5 trophic steps lower than stomach content-derived estimates (TPSC) for all species. Although TPCSIA estimates using dual TDF equations were in better agreement with TPSC estimates for bowhead whales, belugas, and FE killer whales, our data do not support the application of a universal or currently available dual TDFs to estimate cetacean TPs. Discrepancies were not simply due to inaccurate TDFs, however, because the difference between consumer glutamic acid (Glu) and phenylalanine (Phe) δ15N values (δ15NGlu-Phe) did not follow expected TP order, indicating it is not a reliable index of relative TP in these species.
  4. In contrast with pioneering studies on invertebrates and fish, our data suggest trophic 15N enrichment of Phe is not negligible and should be examined among the potential mechanisms driving ‘compressed’ and variable δ15NGlu-Phe values at high TPs. We emphasize the need for controlled diet studies to clearly understand mechanisms driving AA-specific isotopic fractionation before widespread application of CSIA-AA in ecological studies of cetaceans and other marine consumers.