Skip to main content
Dryad logo

The impacts of tropical agriculture on biodiversity: A meta-analysis

Citation

Oakley, Joseph; Bicknell, Jake (2022), The impacts of tropical agriculture on biodiversity: A meta-analysis, Dryad, Dataset, https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.8w9ghx3qn

Abstract

1.   Biodiversity underpins all food production and strengthens agricultural resilience to crop failure. However, agricultural expansion is the primary driver of biodiversity loss, particularly in the tropics where crop production is increasing and intensifying rapidly to meet a growing global food demand. It is therefore crucial to ask, how do different crops and crop production systems impact biodiversity?

2.   We first use the FAO database of harvested crop area to explore temporal changes in crop area and intensification across the entire tropical realm. We show that the harvested area of tropical crops has more than doubled since 1961, with ever-increasing intensification. The harvested area in 2019 was 7.21 million km2, equivalent to 5.5% of global ice-free land area, or 11.5% of land area in the tropics.

3.   Second, we conducted a meta-analysis of 194 studies and 1,364 pairwise comparisons to assess the impact of tropical agriculture on biodiversity, comparing biodiversity values in food crop sites versus natural reference habitats.

4.   Our meta-analysis shows that crop type, rotation time and level of shading are important determinants of biodiversity assemblages. Perennial tropical crops that are grown in shaded plantations or agroforests (e.g., banana and coffee) support higher biodiversity, while crops cultivated in unshaded and often homogeneous croplands (e.g., maize, sugarcane, and oil palm), and particularly annual crops, have impoverished biodiversity communities.

5.   Policy implications: Our findings highlight the increasing agricultural expansion and intensification over the last sixty years and inform our understanding of how different crops and crop production systems impact biodiversity. Furthermore, they provide insight into the long-term sustainability of tropical food production and may serve as a warning sign for agricultural systems that rely on the ecosystem services provided by biodiversity.

Methods

A Rapid Evidence Assessment was conducted to search for relevant literature. From this literature search, data were extracted from tables, figures and the text of relevant papers. These data included the mean biodiversity value in both agricultural and natural reference sites, measures of variance, sample size, and details from the papers.

Usage Notes

Microsoft Excel