Skip to main content
Dryad logo

Resistance-recovery tradeoff of soil microbial communities under altered rain regimes: An experimental test across European agroecosystems


Piton, Gabin et al. (2020), Resistance-recovery tradeoff of soil microbial communities under altered rain regimes: An experimental test across European agroecosystems, Dryad, Dataset,


  1. With the increased occurrence of climate extremes, there is an urgent need to better understand how management strategies affect the capacity of the soil microbial community to maintain its ecosystem functions (e.g. nutrient cycling).
  2. To address this issue, intact monoliths were extracted from conventional and ecological managed grasslands in three countries across Europe and exposed under common air condition (temperature and moisture) to one of three altered rain regimes (dry, wet and intermittent wet/dry) as compared to a normal regime. Subsequently, we compared the resistance and recovery of the soil microbial biomass, potential enzyme activities and community composition.
  3. The microbial community composition differed with soil management and rain regimes. Soil microbial biomass increased from the wetter to the dryer rain regime, paralleling an increase of available carbon and nutrients, suggesting low sensitivity to soil moisture reduction but nutritional limitations of soil microbes. Conversely, enzyme activities decreased with all altered rain regimes.
  4. Resistance and recovery (considering absolute distance between normal and altered rain regime) of the microbial communities depended on soil management. Conventional-intensive management showed higher resistance of two fundamental properties for nutrient cycling (i.e. bacterial biomass and extracellular enzyme activities) yet associated with more important changes in microbial community composition. This suggests an internal community reorganization promoting biomass and activity resistance. Conversely, under ecological management bacterial biomass and enzyme activities showed better recovery capacity, whereas no or very low recovery of these properties was observed under conventional management. These management effects were consistent across the three altered rain regimes investigated, indicating common factors controlling microbial communities’ response to different climate-related stresses.
  5. Synthesis and applications: Our study provides experimental evidence for an important trade-off for agro-ecosystem management between i.) stabilizing nutrient cycling potential during an altered rain regime period at the expense of very low recovery capacity and potential long term effect (conventional sites) and ii.) promoting the capacity of the microbial community to recover its functional potential after the end of the stress (ecological sites). Thus management based on ecologically sound principles may be the best option to sustain long-term soil functioning under climate change.


The experiment was setup using intact soil monoliths extracted at three sites across Europe on October 2015. At each site, soil monoliths were extracted in fields under ecological and conventional management. Ecological managed plots never used synthetic fertilizers and met organic farming requirements. All sites were cultivated for forage at the sampling time: permanent and sown mountain grasslands in France (Vercors), clover-grass in an arable cropping system in Switzerland (Therwil), and permanent and sown grasslands in an agroforestry system in Portugal (Montemor-o-Novo). In total 120 soil monoliths were extracted.

After sampling, monoliths were transported in a climate chamber. During the first 81 days, 50%-60% of the maximum water holding capacity (WHCmax) was maintained followed by a first sampling (T0) of the upper 10 cm of soil for one monolith per plot.

After this acclimation period, 4 rain regimes were simulated during 263 days with the following condition: Normal rain regime : 50%-60% of the WHCmax, ‘Dry’ rain regime : 20%-30%, ‘Wet’ rain regime : 70%-80%  and ‘Intermittent’ rain regime : a cycle of wet (74 days), dry (125 days) and normal (64 days) rain regime. This period was followed by a sampling (T1) of 98 cm3 soil core (5 cm diameter and 5 cm height).

Finaly, all monoliths were then set again to Normal rain regime for 89 days followed by a last destructive sampling (T2) of the upper 10cm of soil as for T0.


Usage Notes

See readme of the data file.