Increasing temperatures in the tropics will reduce performance of trees and agroforestry species and may lead to lasting damage and leaf death. One criterion to determine future forest resilience is to evaluate damage caused by temperature on Photosystem-II (PSII), a particularly sensitive component of photosynthesis. The temperature at which 50% of PSII function is lost (T₅₀) is a widely used measure of irreversible damage to leaves. To assess vulnerability to high temperatures, studies have measured T₅₀ or leaf temperatures, but rarely both. Further, because extant leaf temperature records are short, duration of exposure above thresholds like T₅₀ has not been considered. Finally, these studies do not directly assess the effect of threshold exceedance on leaves. To understand how often, and how long, leaf temperatures exceed critical thresholds, we measured leaf temperatures of forest and agroforestry species in a tropical forest in the Western Ghats of India where air temperatures are high. We quantified species-specific physiological thresholds and assessed leaf damage after high temperature exposure. We found that leaf temperatures already exceed T₅₀. However, continuous exposure durations above critical thresholds are very skewed with most events lasting for much less than 30 minutes. As T₅₀ was measured after a 30-minute exposure, our results suggest that threshold exceedances and exposure durations for lasting damage are currently not reached and will rarely be reached if maximum air temperatures increase by 4°C. Consistent with this, we found only minor indications of heat damage in the forest species. However, there were indications of heat-induced reduction in PSII function and damage in the agroforestry leaves which have lower T₅₀. Our findings suggest that, for forest species, while high temperature thresholds may be surpassed, durations of exposure above thresholds remain short, and therefore, are unlikely to lead to irreversible damage and leaf death, even under 4°C warming.