A multi-state occupancy model to non-invasively monitor visible signs of wildlife health with camera traps that accounts for image quality
Murray, Maureen et al. (2021), A multi-state occupancy model to non-invasively monitor visible signs of wildlife health with camera traps that accounts for image quality, Dryad, Dataset, https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.x3ffbg7js
Camera traps are an increasingly popular tool to monitor wildlife distributions. However, traditional analytical approaches to camera trap data are difficult to apply to visible wildlife characteristics in single images, such as infection status. Several parasites produce visible signs of infection that could be sampled via camera traps. Sarcoptic mange (Sarcoptes scabiei) is an ideal disease to study using cameras because it results in visible hair loss and affects a broad host range.
Here, we developed a multi-state occupancy model to estimate the occurrence of mange in coyotes (Canis latrans) across an urban gradient. This model incorporates a secondary detection function for apparent by-image infection status to provide detection corrected estimates of mange occurrence.
We analyzed a multi-year camera trap dataset in Chicago, Illinois, USA to test whether the apparent occurrence of sarcoptic mange in coyotes (Canis latrans) increases with urbanization or varies through time. We documented visible signs consistent with current or recovering mange infection and variables we hypothesized would improve mange detection: the proportion of the coyote in frame, image blur, and whether the image was in color.
We were more likely to detect coyotes with mange in images that were less blurry, in color, and if a greater proportion of the coyote was visible. Mangy coyote occupancy was significantly higher in urban developed areas with low housing density and higher canopy cover whereas coyote occupancy, mangy or otherwise, decreased with urbanization.
By incorporating image quality into our by-image detection function, we provide a robust method to non-invasively survey visible aspects of wildlife health with camera traps. Apparently mangy coyotes were associated with low-density forested neighborhoods, which may offer vegetated areas while containing sources of anthropogenic resources. This association may contribute to human-wildlife conflict and reinforces posited relationships between infection risk and habitat use. More generally, our model could provide detection-corrected occupancy estimates of visible characteristics that vary by image such as body condition or injuries.
All of the camera trap data came from a large-scale, long term camera trapping survey throughout Chicago. Refer to the manuscript for additional details about the sampling process, or refer to the dryad_readme.pdf for a description of all the data and scripts on this repository.
This repository only holds the data used for this analysis. See the readme.pdf for info about the file structure. If you would like all of the software as well, it can be found on github repository (https://github.com/mfidino/coyote-mange) and zenodo (https://zenodo.org/record/4721850#.YIcpg5BKiUk).