Dodd Frank financial reform at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC): Public comments, January 14th, 2010 – July 16th, 2014
Data files
Oct 24, 2019 version files 474.57 MB
-
(2014-07-30)_CFTC_Original_Codebook.xlsx
17.68 KB
-
DoddFrankCommentsAll(uncompressed).txt
474.55 MB
Jan 10, 2024 version files 474.57 MB
-
(2014-07-30)_CFTC_Original_Codebook.xlsx
17.68 KB
-
DoddFrankCommentsAll(uncompressed).txt
474.55 MB
-
README.md
5.30 KB
Abstract
This dataset includes a complete record of the 36,066 public comments submitted to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) in response to notices of proposed rule-making (NPRMs) implementing the Dodd-Frank Act over a 42-month period (January 14, 2010 to July 16, 2014). The data was exported from the agency’s internal database by the CFTC and provided to the authors by email correspondence following a cold call to the CFTC public relations department. The source internal database is maintained by the CFTC as part of its internal compliance with the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) and includes all rule-making notices that appear in the Federal Register. Owing to the salience and publicity of the Dodd-Frank Act, the CFTC made a special tag in its database for all comments submitted in response to rules proposed under the authority of the Dodd-Frank Act. This database thus includes all comments which the CFTC considers relevant to the Dodd-Frank reform.
In short, the CFTC gave the authors all comments related to the implementation of Dodd-Frank that it received between January 14th, 2010 and July 16th, 2014.
Please note that this dataset includes only public domain data from the CFTC (under the stipulations of the APA, all comments must be published in the Federal Register and thus become public domain information). It should be noted that the CFTC does have additional meta-data which they declined to rovide (i.e. IP addresses for commenters and other personally identifiable information) which they noted could be obtained through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request. We did not pursue this avenue, but future researchers interested in, for example, the geographic distribution of commenters could request such data by using a FOIA request.
README: Dodd Frank Financial Reform at the CFTC - Public Comments, January 14th, 2010 to July 16th, 2014
https://doi.org/10.6078/D1610G
Description of the data and file structure
NOTE: The Comment Text (
There are two files provided:
- DoddFrankCommentsAll(uncompressed).txt - the full raw data file from the CFTC internal database of all 36,066 comments on NPRMs
- (2014-07-30) CFTC Original Codebook.xlsx - the codebook provided by the CTFC with the raw data. Originally provided as email text, formatted in Excel by authors.
Codebook:
Variable | Explanation |
---|---|
ControlNumberID | CFTC assigned control number; unique to each comment |
SubmitDate | Date comment was submitted to CFTC. For comments from the 2010 and early 2011 timeframe, this may be the date the comment was uploaded by CFTC staff, rather than the original submission date. |
UniqueName | This is the Federal Register citation (volume and page number, e.g., XX FR XXXX) tying a comment to the published rulemaking document to which it pertains. |
FirstName | Commenter first name. |
LastName | Commenter last name. |
Organization | Commenter organization (if supplied) |
Title | As noted above, some “comments” are actually records of an ex parte meeting related to a rulemaking. For such items, this column generally indicates who the meeting was with. |
CommentText | This is any data entered by a commenter in the Comment field of the CFTC’s web submission form. This will be the same data that is in the ExtractedText field (see below), if that is all the user entered and they did not attach a document to the submission form. That will also be the case for some older comments that were manually entered on the website by CFTC staff. |
ExtractedText | This is the text pulled from any document that a commenter attached to the CFTC’s web submission form. |
Sharing/Access information
n/a
Code/Software
n/a
Methods
This dataset was exported by the CFTC from their internal database of public comments in response to NPRMs. The uploaded file is the exact raw data generated by the CTFC and provided to the authors.
An updated version of the data file including the author's classifications based on the organization value will be uploaded when the related work is accepted for publication.