Skip to main content
Dryad

Data from: Testing cohesive selective paths and evaluating information loss while delimiting species of Brazilian wandering spiders

Data files

Jun 02, 2026 version files 2.59 GB

Click names to download individual files

Abstract

Biodiversity is structured in nested Retrospective Reproductive Communities (RRCs) reflecting different levels of information about evolutionary processes. Ranking species involves deciding which level to emphasize, based on a trade-off in information gain and loss. Modeling the selective processes that maintain RRCs along distinct evolutionary paths can inform these trade-offs in species delimitation. We illustrate this approach using the Brazilian wandering spiders (Phoneutria). Integrating genetic markers, geometric morphometrics, color patterns, and environmental data, we applied both established and novel models to test historical natural and sexual selection driving divergence. We found evidence that selection on ecological niche and ventral abdominal coloration contributed to the formation of four distinct RRCs. Two of these RRCs also showed evidence of a Lock-and-Key mechanism influencing genital morphology evolution. Despite the distinct cohesive forces, gene flow modeling revealed incomplete reproductive isolation, with potential hybrid individuals. We evaluate the implications of lumping versus splitting these lineages and argue that recognizing all four as distinct species would better preserve evolutionary information and minimize downstream impacts on other research fields such as pharmacology, public health and conservation. Our approach provides a quantitative basis to ponder the implications of choosing between different species hypotheses.