Data from: Northern wild-rice (manoomin) is limited by a warm lake and the co-occurrence of native and non-native aquatic plants in northern Michigan, USA
Data files
Apr 30, 2026 version files 31.51 KB
-
Lishawa_et_al_Study_1.csv
3.62 KB
-
Lishawa_et_al_Study_2.csv
5.65 KB
-
Lishawa_et_al_Study_3.csv
5.72 KB
-
Lishawa_et_al_Study_4.csv
9.55 KB
-
README.md
6.97 KB
Abstract
Zizania palustris (northern wild-rice, manoomin) is foundational to the cultural heritage of indigenous peoples in the Great Lakes region of North America, provides habitat for diverse fauna, and its regional distribution and abundance have been substantially reduced. Restoration and sustainable stewardship of manoomin is a shared goal of tribes across the region. Our research objective was to refine our understanding of manoomin’s ecological niche and competitive dynamics in order to improve restoration outcomes through four related studies: Study one (Q1) evaluated differences between lakes with differing seeding successes; study two (Q2), quantified manoomin growth and environmental conditions within mixed aquatic plant communities; study three (Q3) tested experimental manoomin seeding within three dominant aquatic plant types; and study four (Q4) evaluated the indirect effects of shading and invasive plant (Typha × glauca) litter on manoomin. We found that the warmer of the two lakes sampled had dramatically lower manoomin productivity (Q1); Pontederia cordata was negatively associated with manoomin (Q2); manoomin was more abundant and larger in Nuphar variegata stands (Q3); and litter from T. × glauca and a proxy for floating plant cover reduced germination and early growth (Q4). Our findings illustrate that both native and invasive plants can be detrimental to the germination, growth, and productivity of manoomin. T. × glauca and its litter caused particularly strong negative effects, indicating that invasive plant management is necessary for sustainable restoration. Our study points toward areas for future manoomin research and highlights the multifaceted threats of global change factors (e.g., climate change and non-native macrophytes) on plant species of high cultural importance.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.05qfttfj6
Description of the data and file structure
Our research objective was to refine our understanding of manoomin’s ecological niche and competitive dynamics in order to improve restoration outcomes through four related studies: Study one (Q1) evaluated differences between lakes with differing seeding successes; study two (Q2), quantified manoomin growth and environmental conditions within mixed aquatic plant communities; study three (Q3) tested experimental manoomin seeding within three dominant aquatic plant types; and study four (Q4) evaluated the indirect effects of shading and invasive plant (Typha × glauca) litter on manoomin. The data are organized into these four individual studies.
Files and variables
File: Lishawa_et_al_Study_1.csv
Description: Lake-to-lake comparison study
- date: date collected
- wetland: lake name
- plot: plot
- subplot: subplot ID
- water_depth: water depth (cm)
- organic_depth: organic depth (cm)
- water_temp: Temperature (degrees C)
- spc: specific conductivity (µS / cm)
- pH: pH
- orp: Oxydation-reduction potential (mV)
- nh4: ammonium (NH4+ [mg / L])
- no3: nitrate (NO3- [mg / L])
- cl: Cl- (mg / L)
- zizpal_stem count: Zizania palustris total stems / m2
- zizpal_flowering_stem count: Zizania palustris flowering stems / m2
- zizpal_floating_percent: Zizania palustris percent floating
- zizpal_emergent_percent: Zizania palustris percent emergent
- zizpal_cover_percent: Zizania palustris total percent cover
- shoot length: Zizania palustris sampled shoot length (cm)
- root length: Zizania palustris sampled root length (cm)
- shoot wt: Zizania palustris sampled shoot weight (g)
- root wt: Zizania palustris sampled root weight (g)
File: Lishawa_et_al_Study_2.csv
Description: Dominant plant type observational study
- plot: plot
- plant: plant community type (PC: Pontederia cordata; SA: Schoenoplectus acutus; ZP: Zizania palustris; NV: Nuphar variegata)
- year: year sampled
- total_veg_percent: plant cover (%)
- water_depth: water depth (cm)
- water_temp: Temperature (degrees C)
- pH: pH
- conductivity_ms.cm: specific conductivity (µS / cm)
- DO_mg_per_L: dissolved oxygen (mg / L)
- ORP: Oxidation-reduction potential (mV)
- zp_stem: Zizania palustris total stems / m2
- zp_floating_percent: Zizania palustris percent floating
- zp_emergent_percent: Zizania palustris percent emergent
- zp_cover_percent: Zizania palustris total percent cover
- potber: Potamogeton berchtoldii cover (%)
- potnat: Potamogeton natans cover (%)
- schsub: Schoenoplectus subterminalis cover (%)
- schacu: Schoenoplectus acutus cover (%)
- nupvar: Nuphar variegata cover (%)
- brasch: Brasenia schreberi cover (%)
- potgra: Potamogeton gramineus cover (%)
- najfle: Najas flexilis cover (%)
- chara: Chara spp. cover (%)
- poncor: Pontederia cordata cover (%)
- utrvul: Utricularia vulgaris cover (%)
- utrpur: Utricularia purpurea cover (%)
- clamar: Cladium mariscoides cover (%)
- H: Shannon's diversity index score
- invsimp: inverse Simpson diversity score
- richness: species richness
- evenness: species evenness
File: Lishawa_et_al_Study_3.csv
Description: Dominant plant type experimental seeding study
- year: year sampled
- date: date collected
- veg_type: vegetation community (PC: Pontederia cordata; SA: Schoenoplectus acutus; NV: Nuphar variegata; OW: open water)
- plot: plot
- substrate: substrate type (sand; o [organic])
- organic: organic sediment depth (cm)
- subplot: subplot
- vegcov: total plant cover (%)
- detritusAW: above water detritus cover (%)
- detritusBW: below water detritus cover (%)
- detritusTot: total detritus cover (%)
- water: water depth (cm)
- ziz_present: Zizania palustris present (Y/N)
- ziz_cover: Zizania palustris percent cover (%)
- ziz_stems: Zizania palustris stems (m2)
- ziz_flower: Zizania palustris flowering stems / m2
- ziz_floating: Zizania palustris floating stems / m2
- ziz_emerg: Zizania palustris emergent stems / m2
- ziz_max_height: maximum height of stems within a plot (cm)
- chara: Chara spp. cover (%)
- potnat: Potamogeton natans cover (%)
- schacu: Schoenoplectus acutus cover (%)
- najfle: Najas flexilis cover (%)
- poncor: Pontederia cordata cover (%)
- nupvar: Nuphar variegata cover (%)
- brasch: Brasenia schreberi cover (%)
- nymodo: Nymphaea odorata cover (%)
- utrvul: Utricularia vulgaris cover (%)
- clamar: Cladium mariscoides cover (%)
File: Lishawa_et_al_Study_4.csv
Description: Litter and shading mesocosm experiment
- date: date
- block: block
- mesocosm: mesocosm
- typha_YN: Typha present (Y/N)
- level: treatment (Typha, Low, High, Control)
- rootWeight_seeds_g: weight of total roots with attached seeds (g)
- rootWeight_noSeeds_g: weight of total roots without attached seeds (g)
- seedWeight_g: weight of seeds (g)
- rootWeight_avg_seeds_g: average weight of roots with attached seeds (g)
- rootWeight_avg_noSeeds_g: average weight of roots without attached seeds (g)
- seedWeight_g_avg: average weight of seeds (g)
- shootWeight_g: shoot weight total (g)
- shootWeight_avg_g: shoot weight average (g)
- root_count: root counts (#)
- rootLength_avg: root length average (cm)
- rootLength_sum: root length total (cm)
- shoot_count: total shoots (#)
- shootLength_avg: shoot lengths average (cm)
- shootLength_sum: shoot lengths sum (cm)
- root_to_shoot_avg: root to shoot ratio of averages
- Na_ppm_shoot: Na+ ppm shoot tissue (PPM)
- NH4_ppm_shoot: NH4+ shoot tissue (PPM)
- K_ppm_shoot: K+ shoot tissue (PPM)
- Ca_ppm_shoot: Ca+ shoot tissue (PPM)
- Mg_ppm_shoot: Mg+ shoot tissue (PPM)
- Na_ppm_root: Na+ ppm root tissue (PPM)
- NH4_ppm_root: NH4+ root tissue (PPM)
- K_ppm_root: K+ root tissue (PPM)
- Ca_ppm_root: Ca+ root tissue (PPM)
- Mg_ppm_root: Mg+ root tissue (PPM)
- f_ppm_water: F water (ppm)
- cl_ppm_water: Cl- water (ppm)
- NO2_ppm_water: NO2- water (ppm)
- Br_ppm_water: Br- water (ppm)
- NO3_ppm_water: NO3- water (ppm)
- PO4_ppm_water: PO4 water (ppm)
- SO4_ppm_water: SO4 water (ppm)
Note
All NAs in the data set represent data that are not available.
Code/software
CSV files can be viewed in a variety of free software, including R.
Access information
NA
