Where do Gyps fulvus (Griffon Vultures) feed? Combining biologging with socio-economic analysis can guide sustainable ecotourism development
Data files
Jul 08, 2025 version files 23.73 MB
-
CovariatesPPM_20241016.tif
23.54 MB
-
FeedingEvents_Pooled_04Apr2024.Rdata
44.17 KB
-
README.md
4.40 KB
-
Sardinia_EPSG32632.cpg
5 B
-
Sardinia_EPSG32632.dbf
303 B
-
Sardinia_EPSG32632.prj
400 B
-
Sardinia_EPSG32632.qmd
659 B
-
Sardinia_EPSG32632.shp
123.71 KB
-
Sardinia_EPSG32632.shx
108 B
-
Script.R
24.79 KB
Abstract
Ecotourism supports Old World vulture conservation and raises public awareness of their ecological role. Traditional vulture-watching activities are often based at hides near supplementary feeding stations, where vultures predictably gather. However, identifying optimal locations for sustainable vulture-watching ecotourism beyond these sites is challenging considering that vultures travel extensive distances to locate carrion. We analyzed movement data from six Gyps fulvus (Griffon Vultures) in northwest Sardinia, Italy, to identify areas where they usually feed and where economically viable birdwatching activities could be implemented. G. fulvus were equipped with GPS tags and tri-axial accelerometer sensors. Using a random forest algorithm, we identified feeding events from the acceleration data and fitted a Poisson process model to predict feeding event density across the study area. Additionally, we conducted structured questionnaires with 116 visitors to protected area (August 2022 – October 2023) to assess their willingness to pay for vulture-watching activities. From 2020 to 2024, we recorded 1,563 feeding events, primarily in areas with scarce forest cover and low slope, and adjacent to the main colony. Most respondents expressed interest in visiting observation hides and guided tours, with an average willingness to pay of €13–15. Based on these responses, we estimated potential revenues of €415.51, €41,551.27, and €415,512.72, assuming participation from 0.001%, 0.1%, and 1% of visitors from Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States, respectively. Additional income from related tourism services could further increase these revenues. Our findings represent the first attempt to combine high-resolution biologging to map the foraging areas of an unpredictable yet ecologically significant wildlife species with data from structured consumer questionnaires. This approach allows for the assessment and potential implementation of an ecotourism model that does not depend on predictable supplementary feeding stations, offering ecological, behavioral, and sanitary advantages.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.612jm64h4
Description of the data and file structure
The following zipped folder contains the data and software code, to replicate the analyses for the study entitled "Where do Gyps fulvus (Griffon Vultures) feed? Combining biologging with socio-economic analysis can guide sustainable ecotourism development"
The script ("Script.R") replicates the analyses in R. Namely, the script runs a Poisson Process Model (PPM) in spatstat (https://spatstat.org/), to estimate the density of feeding events according to relevant environmental covariates. Analyses were carried out in R version 4.4.3 (2025-02-28) -- "Trophy Case"
This contains all the main datasets required for fitting the Poisson Process Model. Namely
"Sardinia_EPSG32632.shp", "Sardinia_EPSG32632.cpg", "Sardinia_EPSG32632.qmd", "Sardinia_EPSG32632.shx", "Sardinia_EPSG32632.prj", "Sardinia_EPSG32632.dbf", "Sardinia_EPSG32632.shp" - The boundaries of Sardinia, in the epsg: 32632 CRS
"FeedingEvents_Pooled_04Apr2024.Rdata" - A dataset of 1,563 centroids of feeding events, identified from accelerometers. Each row is a feeding event, characterized by the following variables:
- "id", the identifier of each feeding event
- "avg.timestamp", the timestamp of each feeding event
- "week", the week of each feeding event
- "month", the month of each feeding event
- "yday", the day of the year of each feeding event
- "lon", the longitude of each feeding event (epsg:4326)
- "lat", the longitude of each feeding event (epsg:4326)
- "lon.utm", the longitude of each feeding event (epsg:32632)
- "lat.utm", the longitude of each feeding event (epsg:32632)
"CovariatesPPM_20241016.tif" - A SpatRaster object, created with the terra package (https://rspatial.github.io/terra/), containing the covariates used for point-process modeling in spatstat (https://spatstat.org/). The stacked raster has a resolution of 250 m and its layers are:
- "slope", the slope of each cell, measured from a 250 m DEM
- "dist.col", the euclidean distance between the centroid of each cell and the
closest colony
- "dist.sfs", the euclidean distance between the centroid of each cell and the
closest supplementary feeding station
- "dist.urb", the euclidean distance between the centroid of each cell and the
closest human settlement
- "dist.roads", the euclidean distance between the centroid of each cell and the
closest road (from Geofabrik.de)
- "tree", tree coverage according to the MODIS Terra Vegetation Continuous Fields
Yearly Global 250m
- "updrafts", the updraft suitability index developed by Scacco et al. (2019, see:
https://doi.org/10.1098/rsos.181440)
- "dist.coast", the euclidea distance between the centroid of each cell and the
coastline
- "lon.utm", the longitude of the centroid of each cell (epsg:3262)
- "lat.utm", the latitude of the centroid of each cell (epsg:3262)
- "pc1", the first principal component, from PCA (see the Methods)
- "pc2", the second principal component, from PCA (see the Methods)
- "pc3", the third principal component, from PCA (see the Methods)
- "pc4", the fourth principal component, from PCA (see the Methods)
For further information about the data or the code please contact prof. Fiammetta Berlinguer (berling@uniss.it)
Funding
The following study was co-financed by the European Commission through the LIFE "Under Griffon Wings" (LIFE14 NAT/IT/000484) and the LIFE "Safe for Vultures" (LIFE19 NAT/IT/000732) projects. Chiara Costantino was supported by the Italian Ministry of Education, University and Research, through the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (PNRR) - “Budget di ricerca borse 118 - Pianificazione territoriale integrata, finalizzata a massimizzare la compatibilità tra lo sviluppo delle energie rinnovabili e le comunità faunistiche della Regione Sardegna”. Grant number: UA2003DOTTRIC39_118. Ilaria Fozzi was supported by the Italian Ministry of Education, University and Research—PON ricerca innovazione 2014-2020, Azione IV.5 “Dottorati su tematiche Green”, Grant number: DOT1629893-2.
