Data from: Saving bees or sustaining industry? Challenging neoliberal narratives in North American pollinator research and conservation
Data files
Jun 16, 2026 version files 3.46 KB
Abstract
To explore the growing scientific interest in bees and insect pollinators, in March 2025 we conducted an analysis of bibliometric trends for terms related to pollinator conservation using Google Scholar; these included “pollinator conservation”, “bee conservation”, “butterfly conservation”, and “colony collapse” + “honey bee”. We chose butterflies as a similarly charismatic insect “control” taxon for comparison, an approach which has previously been used to compare public attitudes to various insect taxa. For each term, we tallied the number of results returned for each year from 2000-2024. To assess whether the terms used to refer to pollinators and justify their conservation are linked to such economic rationale, we conducted additional searches and calculated the proportion of search results for each of the terms listed above that also included the term “ecosystem services”. This analysis was conducted to inform a Perspective piece on the pollinator research community.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.80gb5mm56
Description of the data and file structure
To inform a Perspective piece on research priorities among pollinator researchers, bibliometric trends in peer-reviewed pollinator research from 2000-2025 were evaluated using Google Scholar.
Files and variables
File: Pollinator_research_bibliometric_trends_article_counts.csv
Description: Counts of peer-reviewed articles indexed in Google Scholar containing the reference phrases in each year from 2000-2025
Variables
- Year: Year of article publication
- ""Colony collapse"" ""Honey bee"": Articles containing both these phrases
- ""Pollinator conservation"": Articles containing this phrase
- ""Bee conservation"": Articles containing this phrase
- ""Butterfly conservation"": Articles containing this phrase
File: Pollinator_research_bibliometric_trends_proportion_ES.csv
Description: Proportion of the peer-reviewed articles indexed in Google Scholar containing the reference phrase that also include the phrase "ecosystem services" in each year from 2000-2025
Variables
- Year: Year of article publication
- ""Bee conservation"": Proportion of the articles containing the phrase "Bee conservation" that also contained "Ecosystem services"
- ""Pollinator conservation"": Proportion of the articles containing the phrase "Pollinator conservation" that also contained "Ecosystem services"
- ""Butterfly conservation"": Proportion of the articles containing the phrase "Butterfly conservation" that also contained "Ecosystem services"
