Dental morphometric and paleoclimate data for investigating climate-linked evolution in Phenacolemur from the late Paleocene–early Eocene Bighorn Basin
Data files
Nov 17, 2026 version files 621.04 KB
-
MAT_interpolation_curve.csv
280 B
-
Phenacolemur_Reproducibility_Supplement.qmd
54.43 KB
-
Phenacolemur_with_ClimatePhase.csv
228.65 KB
-
Raw_Data_Phenacolemur_JPA.csv
159.84 KB
-
Raw_Data_Phenacolemur_JPA.xlsx
165.41 KB
-
README.md
12.42 KB
Abstract
This dataset contains 474 dental records of Phenacolemur from the late Paleocene through early Eocene of the Bighorn Basin, Wyoming, USA. It combines published and newly collected dental measurements with specimen identifications, stratigraphic information, assigned geological ages, and reconstructed mean annual temperatures. The associated study used 313 specimens to examine how six dental traits varied with temperature across three climate phases. The deposit also includes measurements from tooth positions outside the analytical sample and the paleoclimate calibration data used to estimate temperatures for the fossil records.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.f4qrfj7cc
This dataset combines published and newly collected dental measurements of Phenacolemur with stratigraphic information, assigned fossil ages, and reconstructed mean annual temperatures for the late Paleocene through early Eocene in the Bighorn Basin, Wyoming, USA. The compilation contains 474 records; some museum catalog numbers occur in multiple rows. It includes tooth positions beyond the six traits examined in the manuscript’s analytical sample of 313 specimens.
Description of the data and file structure
Raw_Data_Phenacolemur_JPA.xlsxandRaw_Data_Phenacolemur_JPA.csv: Excel and CSV versions of the same 64-column compilation. The workbook is the input to the Quarto workflow. Some calculated values differ slightly in numerical precision because of rounding during CSV export.Phenacolemur_with_ClimatePhase.csv: Derived file with the same records and 64 columns, plusInterpolated_MATandClimatePhase.MAT_interpolation_curve.csv: Nine age–temperature calibration points used to assign mean annual temperature (MAT) to fossil records.Phenacolemur_Reproducibility_Supplement.qmd: Quarto source for the analysis.
Missing values are represented by blank cells in Raw_Data_Phenacolemur_JPA.xlsx and Raw_Data_Phenacolemur_JPA.csv and NA in MAT_interpolation_curve.csv. Treat these values as missing rather than zero. The observations available for a particular model depend on which records have the required measurements and predictors.
Columns shared by the raw and derived fossil files
Lowercase tooth letters denote lower teeth (for example, p4); uppercase tooth letters denote upper teeth (for example, P4). Linear dental measurements are in millimeters (mm), and area variables are in square millimeters (mm²). Prefixes ln and Ln indicate natural logarithms. Capitalization and numeric suffixes below follow the files.
Specimen and geological context
| Column | Definition |
|---|---|
Museum no. |
Museum collection identifier and catalog number. Identifiers may occur in more than one row. |
Species |
Taxonomic identification, including intermediate forms where recorded. |
Specimen |
Description of the preserved material, including tooth positions and side where recorded. The prefixes l and r indicate left and right. |
Locality |
Fossil collection locality identifier. |
Stratigraphic Section |
Stratigraphic section or correlated regional framework used to place the specimen. |
ML |
Stratigraphic meter level (m) within the section or correlated composite framework identified for the record; levels from different sections are not necessarily directly comparable. |
ML Reference |
Source of the stratigraphic meter-level assignment. |
Age_Ma |
Assigned geological age, in millions of years before present (Ma). Larger values indicate older ages. |
Geochronological tie point |
Magnetochron or other geochronological marker used in the age assignment. |
Age Calibration Reference |
Reference for the numerical age calibration. |
Age Model |
Section-specific chronological framework used to assign the specimen age. |
Dental and mandibular measurements
| Column | Definition |
|---|---|
p4L |
Lower fourth premolar length (mm). |
Lnp4L |
Natural logarithm (base e) of p4L, using its numerical value in mm. |
p4W |
Lower fourth premolar width (mm). |
Lnp4W |
Natural logarithm (base e) of p4W, using its numerical value in mm. |
p4area |
Lower fourth premolar area variable (mm²). |
Lnp4area |
Natural logarithm (base e) of p4area, using its numerical value in mm². |
p4prtcdhei |
Lower fourth premolar protoconid height (mm). |
Lnp4pH |
Natural logarithm (base e) of p4prtcdhei, using its numerical value in mm. |
p4H |
Lower fourth premolar crown height (mm). |
lnp4H |
Natural logarithm (base e) of p4H, using its numerical value in mm. |
m1L |
Lower first molar length (mm). |
lnm1L |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m1L, using its numerical value in mm. |
m1W |
Lower first molar width (mm). |
lnm1W |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m1W, using its numerical value in mm. |
m1area |
Lower first molar area variable (mm²). |
Lnm1area |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m1area, using its numerical value in mm². |
m2L |
Lower second molar length (mm). |
lnm2L |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m2L, using its numerical value in mm. |
m2W |
Lower second molar width (mm). |
lnm2W |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m2W, using its numerical value in mm. |
m2area |
Lower second molar area variable (mm²). |
Lnm2area |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m2area, using its numerical value in mm². |
m3L |
Lower third molar length (mm). |
Lnm3L |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m3L, using its numerical value in mm. |
m3W |
Lower third molar width (mm). |
lnm3W |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m3W, using its numerical value in mm. |
m3area |
Lower third molar area variable (mm²). |
Lnm3area |
Natural logarithm (base e) of m3area, using its numerical value in mm². |
mand.depth |
Mandibular depth (mm). |
lnmanddepth |
Natural logarithm (base e) of mand.depth, using its numerical value in mm. |
p4m1L |
Recorded length spanning the lower fourth premolar and first molar (mm). |
Lnp4m1L |
Natural logarithm (base e) of p4m1L, using its numerical value in mm. |
P2L |
Upper second premolar length (mm). |
P2W |
Upper second premolar width (mm). |
P2area |
Upper second premolar area variable (mm²). |
P3L |
Upper third premolar length (mm). |
P3W |
Upper third premolar width (mm). |
P3area |
Upper third premolar area variable (mm²). |
P4L |
Upper fourth premolar length (mm). |
P4W |
Upper fourth premolar width (mm). |
P4area |
Upper fourth premolar area variable (mm²). |
M1L |
Upper first molar length (mm). |
M1W |
Upper first molar width (mm). |
M1area |
Upper first molar area variable (mm²). |
M2L |
Upper second molar length (mm). |
M2W |
Upper second molar width (mm). |
M2area |
Upper second molar area variable (mm²). |
M3L |
Upper third molar length (mm). |
M3W |
Upper third molar width (mm). |
M3area |
Upper third molar area variable (mm²). |
i1W |
Lower first incisor width (mm). |
i1H |
Lower first incisor height (mm). |
i1L |
Lower first incisor length (mm). |
Columns added in Phenacolemur_with_ClimatePhase.csv
Interpolated_MAT: Estimated MAT (°C), obtained by linear interpolation of the calibration temperatures at each fossil record’sAge_Ma. For ages outside the calibration range, R’sapprox(..., rule = 2)assigns the nearest endpoint temperature.ClimatePhase: Age-based category. Warming Phase 1 includes ages of 55.930 Ma or older; Cooling includes ages younger than 55.930 Ma and at least 54.530 Ma; Warming Phase 2 includes ages younger than 54.530 Ma. The labels describe broad regional trends.
Columns in MAT_interpolation_curve.csv
| Column | Definition |
|---|---|
Site |
Name of the paleoclimate calibration locality or interval. |
Age_Ma |
Assigned age of the calibration point in millions of years before present (Ma). |
MAT |
Leaf-margin-based estimate of mean annual temperature (°C). |
MAT_error |
Reported uncertainty of the calibration estimate (°C). This uncertainty is not interpolated to individual fossil records. |
Sharing and access information
Dental measurements were compiled from Silcox et al. (2008), Secord (2008), and new measurements for the associated study. The paleoclimate calibration localities follow Currano (2008); the temperature estimates draw on Currano (2009), Currano et al. (2008, 2010), and the compilation in Currano et al. (2021). The source of each stratigraphic level and the age calibration or model used are recorded in the fossil files where available. See the associated manuscript and its journal supplementary materials for measurement protocols and additional calibration details.
When citing the dataset, also acknowledge the original publications for measurements and reconstructions you reuse.
Code and software
The Quarto workflow (Phenacolemur_Reproducibility_Supplement.qmd) starts with the assigned specimen ages in the Excel workbook. It reproduces MAT interpolation, climate-phase assignment, generalized additive models, derivative analyses, and graphical and tabular outputs. The original manual assignment of specimen ages is described in the manuscript.
To run the workflow, use Quarto and R (the report was rendered with R 4.5.1). Install the packages loaded in the source: readxl, dplyr, ggplot2, mgcv, gratia, here, readr, tidyr, scales, ggrepel, patchwork, and rlang. The source expects data/Raw Data Phenacolemur JPA.xlsx. If the downloaded workbook uses underscores, update the workbook name in the source or place a copy with the expected name in the data/ folder. Run from the project folder so that relative paths resolve.
Data sources cited above
Currano, E.D., 2008, Variations in insect herbivory on angiosperm leaves through the late Paleocene and early Eocene in the Bighorn Basin, Wyoming, USA: The Pennsylvania State University.
Currano, E.D., 2009, Patchiness and long-term change in early Eocene insect feeding damage: Paleobiology, v. 35, no. 4, p. 484–498, doi:10.1666/0094-8373-35.4.484.
Currano, E.D., Azevedo-Schmidt, L.E., Maccracken, S.A. and Swain, A., 2021, Scars on fossil leaves: An exploration of ecological patterns in plant–insect herbivore associations during the Age of Angiosperms: Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, v. 582, p. 110636. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2021.110636.
Currano, E.D., Labandeira, C.C., and Wilf, P., 2010, Fossil insect folivory tracks paleotemperature for six million years: Ecological Monographs, v. 80, no. 4, p. 547–567, https://doi.org/10.1890/09-2138.1.
Currano, E.D., Wilf, P., Wing, S.L., Labandeira, C.C., Lovelock, E.C., and Royer, D.L., 2008, Sharply increased insect herbivory during the Paleocene–Eocene Thermal Maximum: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, v. 105, no. 6, p. 1960–1964, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0708646105.
Secord, R., 2008, The Tiffanian land-mammal age (middle and late Paleocene) in the northern Bighorn Basin, Wyoming: University of Michigan Papers on Paleontology, v. 35, 192 p.
Silcox, M.T., Rose, K.D., and Bown, T.M., 2008, Early Eocene Paromomyidae (Mammalia, Primates) from the southern Bighorn Basin, Wyoming: Systematics and evolution: Journal of Paleontology, v. 82, no. 6, p. 1074–1113, https://doi.org/10.1666/07-046.1.
Dental measurements in the analytical sample came from Silcox et al. (2008; 282 specimens), Secord (2008; nine specimens), and new measurements collected for this study (22 specimens). The six traits analyzed were lower fourth premolar length, width, crown height, and protoconid height, and lower first molar length and width. Length was measured as the maximum mesiodistal dimension, and width as the maximum dimension perpendicular to length. Following Silcox et al. (2008), crown height was measured from the protoconid apex to a perpendicular line tangent to the base of the hypoconid, excluding the mesiobasal expansion where present. Protoconid height was measured along the same axis to the level where the cristid obliqua contacts the distal aspect of the protoconid. Teeth preserved in dentaries were oriented anatomically; isolated teeth were oriented by comparison with dentary specimens of the same species.
Fossil ages were assigned using section-specific stratigraphic correlations and updated age calibrations. Mean annual temperature (MAT) was estimated for each fossil age by linear interpolation between nine leaf-margin temperature calibration points. All recorded fossil ages fell within the calibration range. Climate phases were assigned by age: Warming Phase 1 includes ages of 55.930 Ma or older; Cooling includes ages younger than 55.930 Ma and at least 54.530 Ma; Warming Phase 2 includes ages younger than 54.530 Ma. The associated manuscript and Quarto source provide the statistical model specifications.
