Skip to main content
Dryad

Data from: Whose success counts? Reconciling stakeholder goals in Madagascar's reforestation policy

Data files

Nov 10, 2026 version files 128.14 KB

Click names to download individual files

Abstract

This dataset supports the article “Whose success counts? Reconciling stakeholder goals in Madagascar’s reforestation policy”. It contains de-identified and aggregated data derived from 62 semi-structured interviews, 101 focus-group discussions and 101 fuzzy cognitive mapping exercises conducted between 2024 and 2025 across four protected-area landscapes in Madagascar: Ambohitantely, Ankafobe, Ankarafantsika and Andasibe. The research involved 333 participants representing government and local authorities, non-governmental and technical organisations, community leaders and local community members.

The dataset documents stakeholder perceptions of the ecological, social, technical, economic and institutional factors influencing reforestation outcomes. It includes a summary of participant numbers by landscape and stakeholder group; a lookup table linking 442 participant-defined raw factors to 191 harmonised factors; signed and weighted fuzzy cognitive mapping data in which causal relationships range from −4, indicating a very strong negative relationship, to +4, indicating a very strong positive relationship; stakeholder-level aggregated adjacency matrices; and Katz centrality scores and rankings used to identify structurally prominent factors within each stakeholder network. Where no relationship between two factors was identified, the corresponding value is zero. Analysis code and supporting documentation are included where applicable.

The dataset can be reused to examine stakeholder-defined reforestation systems, compare perceptions of restoration constraints and enabling conditions, reproduce the network analysis and centrality rankings, test alternative network metrics, and support comparative research on restoration governance and stakeholder participation. Centrality values represent the structural prominence of factors within perceived causal networks and should not be interpreted as independently demonstrated causal effects.

The research was conducted with permission, including ethical approval for data collection, from Madagascar’s Ministry of Environment and Sustainable Development under permits 361/24/MEDD/SG/DGGE/DAPRNE/SCBE.Re and 206/225/MEDD/SG/DGGE/DAPRNE/SCBE.Re. All participants provided free, prior, and informed consent before participation. To protect participant confidentiality, the archived files exclude names, contact information, consent forms, audio recordings, photographs of participants, raw interview and focus-group transcripts, and other directly identifying information. Individual-level materials that could enable participant re-identification are not publicly shared. Users should appropriately cite the dataset and respect the ethical conditions under which the original information was collected.