Rapid male benefit adaptation in response to sex-limitation, mates, and genetic context in Drosophila melanogaster
Data files
Sep 21, 2026 version files 115.54 KB
-
CG_CRF_combined.csv
26.71 KB
-
M_CRF_combined.csv
13.28 KB
-
M_MC_combined.csv
41.08 KB
-
M_MH_CG.csv
4.11 KB
-
M_SC_combined.csv
22.05 KB
-
README.md
8.31 KB
Abstract
Intralocus sexual conflict (IaSC) arises when selection favours different trait values in females and males despite shared genetic architecture. Sex-limited selection can resolve IaSC by allowing one sex to adapt without constraint from the other, but intersexual genetic correlations are expected to reduce opposite-sex fitness. In a recent study, male-limited (ML) selection produced the predicted decline in female fitness, but male fitness gains depended on genetic background, suggesting additional sources of adaptation. Here, we dissect these responses using a fully factorial assay that accounts for the unusual genetic features of the clone-generator (CG) system and its specialized CG females. Male fitness increased by >100% under the full CG context, by ~66% when only CG genetic background, by 26% with only CG females, versus 6% in completely control conditions. Despite this context dependence, male adaptation consistently involved precopulatory traits, with increased attractiveness, mating success, and reduced mating latency, while postcopulatory traits remained unchanged. Evolved males also inflicted less mate harm on CG females. Together, these results support IaSC through male-benefit adaptation alongside female costs, while demonstrating that evolutionary responses are shaped by the genetic and mating context imposed by experimental design.
Estimates of fitness, mate choice, sperm offense and mate harm under male limited experimental evolution.
Associated Publication
- Title: Rapid male benefit adaptation in response to sex-limitation, mates, and genetic context in Drosophila melanogaster.
- Journal: Evolution
- Authors:
- Harshavardhan Thyagarajan,
- Mindy G. Baroody,
- Imran Sayyed,
- Joshua A. Kowal,
- Troy Day,
- Adam K. Chippindale
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/evolut/qpag162
Dataset Overview
This dataset contains experimental data on fitness, mate choice, sperm competition and mate harm measurements for male-limited and control populations. The data pertains to experimentally evolved Drosophila melanogaster populations. The data are provided as CSV files.
The five files correspond to different experimental assays:
M_CRF_combined.csv— Male competitive reproductive fitness assayM_MC_combined.csv— Male mating competition assayM_SC_combined.csv— Male sperm competition assayM_MH_CG.csv— Male mate harm assayCG_CRF_combined.csv— Male and female competitive reproductive fitness assays - conducted on animals carrying a component of the clone generator genetic background.
Common variables:
- Selection
ML — Male limited
MC — Matched control (matched by replicate number, for example ML1 and MC1) - Female
C — Control like females
CG — Clone generator females - Genetic background
C — Control like
CG — Clone generator like - Replicate — This describes the replicate pairs of selected and control populations.
- Contest — An identifier for a distinct chamber in which an assay was conducted.
File Details
1. M_CRF_combined.csv
- Dimensions: 667 rows × 7 columns
- Columns:
Selection— Described above, categoricalFemale— Described above, categoricalGenetic Background— Described above, categoricalReplicate— Described above, categoricalContest— Described above, categoricalRed— Number of wild type progeny, countU— Number of mutant progeny, count
2. M_MC_combined.csv
- Dimensions: 1155 rows × 11 columns
- Columns:
Selection— Described above, categoricalFemale— Described above, categoricalGenetic Background— Described above, categoricalReplicate— Described above, categoricalContest— Described above, categoricalObs.start.time— Observation start time (in the form of minutes from an arbitrary common zero for the assay)Mating.start.time— Time when mating began (in the form of minutes from an arbitrary common zero for the assay)Mating.end.time— Time when mating ended (in the form of minutes from an arbitrary common zero for the assay)Mated.male— Identity of mating male (wt - aka target / bw - recessive competitor), categoricalOffspring_m— Number of male offspring, countOffspring_f— Number of female offspring, count
3. M_SC_combined.csv
- Dimensions: 1152 rows × 7 columns
- Columns:
Selection— Described above, categoricalFemale— Described above, categoricalGenetic Background— Described above, categoricalReplicate— Described above, categoricalContest— Described above, categoricalWT— Number of red-eyed progeny, countU— Number of mutant progeny, count
4. M_MH_CG.csv
- Dimensions: 120 rows × 13 columns
- Columns:
Selection— Described above, categoricalGenetic Background— Described above, categoricalReplicate— Described above, categoricalContest— Described above, categoricalProductivity— Number of offspring (pupal form), countDay0, Day1 ... Day7(8 columns) — Number of surviving females, days counted from day of male introduction (day0), count
5. CG_CRF_combined.csv
- Dimensions: 1081 rows × 9 columns
- Columns:
Selection— Described above, categoricalSex— Sex of target flies (M or F), categoricalReplicate— Described above, categoricalContest— Described above, categoricalCyto— Cytoplasm type of target animal (Control like C, or Clone generator like CG), categoricalAuto— Autosome type of target animal (Control like C, or Clone generator like CG), categoricalY— Y chromosome type of target animal (Control like C, or Clone generator like CG), categoricalWT— Number of red-eyed progeny, countU— Number of mutant progeny, count
Methods
Breeding designs used to produce animals from various treatments can be found in the online supplement of the associated publication.
- Competitive reproductive fitness CRF was measured as competitive siring/damming success from mating arenas
(ventilated ½ pint bottles, with ~7 mL of food) containing 30 target animals combined with 30
marked competitors of the same sex and 50 individuals of the opposite sex. Reproductive success
was measured by phenotyping the progeny using eye colour. In assays using CG females, we
assessed 10 such competition arenas for both MLs and MCs within each replicate; and collected
all the eggs laid (typically yielding 1-2 vials of ~80 viable individuals). For all other CRF assays,
we assessed 6 such competition arenas and collected 6 vials of ~80 eggs. The fully factorial CRF
assay across genetic background and female type was performed at generation 64, and the CG
component male CRF assays were conducted over generations 68–72. CG-cyto and CG-auto
female CRF was assayed in generation 83. - Mating success: Female mate choice (or male-male competition) was assayed in generation 66 by
combining a single virgin female (CG or competitor) with a target male and competitor male in
vials with ~4mL food. We identified the sire by phenotyping the progeny using eye colour. The
resulting brood was also sexed and enumerated to test for fecundity induction (male influence on
female egg output) and sex ratio. Matings were observed to estimate mating latency and
copulation duration. For each treatment (within each replicate pair of lines), we assessed 50 such
competition vials - Sperm competition (P2): Sperm offense (P2) was assayed (in generation 74) by first mating groups of virgin CG or
competitor females with marker-matched competitor males in vials (12 female–male pairs per
vial; ~4 mL food). Following removal of the competitor males under brief CO₂ anesthesia,
females were held for 24 hours before being exposed to focal males (10 per vial). From each
vial, 10 randomly selected females were then transferred to individual egg-laying tubes, yielding
10 P2 estimates per competition vial. P2 was scored as the proportion of offspring sired by the
focal males, with 30 replicate competition vials scored per treatment within each replicate line
pair. - Mate harm assays: Mate harm was assayed (in generation 76) by measuring CG female mortality and
productivity in response to being exposed to males. Following the crossing design, eggs of test
animals were collected to produce densities of ~80 larvae per vial. Test males were collected on
day 10-11. On day 12, 10 test males were combined in vials with 12 virgin CG females of the
same age, in vials with ~4mL food. Flies were held together for days 12-14, at which point the
males were removed from the females using gentle anaesthesia. Female mortality was recorded
daily for 7 days starting with the introduction of males, and the productivity of the females post
mating was measured in the form of pupal counts.
License
This dataset is released under the CC0 1.0 Universal license in accordance with Dryad’s policies.
Citation
If using this data, please cite the associated article, and / or:
Thyagarajan, H. et al. (2026). Rapid male benefit adaptation in response to sex-limitation, mates, and genetic context in Drosophila melanogaster.
Dryad Digital Repository. DOI: 10.5061/dryad.r2280gbv8
