Skip to main content
Dryad

Is the deuterostome clade an artefact?

Data files

Jun 19, 2025 version files 22.31 GB
Jun 20, 2025 version files 22.31 GB

Select up to 11 GB of files for download

Abstract

There is a long-standing consensus that the animal phyla closest to our own phylum of Chordata are the Echinodermata and Hemichordata. These three phyla constitute the major clade of Deuterostomia. Recent analyses have questioned the support for the monophyly of Deuterostomia, however, showing that the branch leading to deuterostomes is very short and may be influenced by systematic error. Here we use a site-by-site approach to explore possible sources of error. Under conditions that promote long-branch attraction (LBA) – especially branch-length heterogeneity and sites constrained in their amino acid composition – we find that deuterostome monophyly is strongly supported. When we make efforts to mitigate these sources of error, support for Deuterostomia markedly decreases or even disappears. Our results call into question one of the longest established major branches of the animal kingdom. A very short, or non-existent, deuterostome branch has implications for interpretating putative deuterostome fossils and for reconstructing the bilaterian ancestor.