Moth communities are more diverse in the understory than in the canopy of a tropical lowland rainforest in NW Ecuador
Data files
Apr 01, 2026 version files 2.30 MB
Abstract
Tropical rainforests are the most species-rich terrestrial habitats and provide distinct niches for specialization and speciation, in part due to their vertical stratification. Stratification is observed in many insect orders as a result of abiotic factors, resource availability, competition and behavior. Here, we investigate the stratification of five clades of Lepidoptera: Erebidae-Arctiinae, Geometridae, Hedylidae, Saturniidae and Sphingidae, which differ in many aspects of their ecology and traits. The study was carried out in a tropical rain forest of the Chocó region in NW Ecuador. We used funnel traps equipped with weak UV-lamps to sample moths simultaneously in the canopy and understory in four forest habitats. We identified species using reference collections and DNA barcoding and present a qualitatively unique database for Neotropical rainforests, with 12,472 individuals of 676 species collected in 48 nightly catches. Average species richness was higher in the understory (73.54 ± 22.58) than in the canopy (59.09 ± 17.24), and median sample sizes were similar (understory: 217.5 (160.5 - 336), canopy: 187.5 (138 - 328.5)). We found taxon-specific patterns: Arctiinae and Sphingidae – the stronger flyers – were more species-rich and abundant in the canopy, and weaker flyers Geometridae and Saturniidae were more species-rich and abundant in the understory. We assume that predation pressure, availability of nectar and host plants shape the vertical distribution of moth assemblages. Communities largely overlapped, were highly nested in each stratum and between habitat types, and differences in composition among habitats were mainly driven by elevation. We found more species in regenerating forests compared to old growth forests, while sample size was independent of the abiotic factors elevation, temperature, humidity. Our results allow a comprehensive insight into differences in stratification of five moth clades in a tropical rainforest at high taxonomic resolution with respect to habitat types and influences of environmental factors.
Publication
The dataset for Böttger, Diniz, Keller, Leonhardt & Brehm (2026): 'Moth communities are more diverse in the understory than in the canopy of a tropical lowland rainforest in NW Ecuador' can be accessed at Dryad.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.w3r22816r
The corresponding paper is available as open access in Ecology and Evolution: https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.73337
Significance
This study represents a qualitatively unique data set for Neotropical rainforests, because it covers all individuals of five Lepidoptera taxa.
Sampling
The data set contains moth recordings of field surveys conducted in tropical rainforests in the Río Canandé reserve (0.5263°N, 79.2130°W), from October to December 2021 and March to May 2022. The study region is in Esmeraldas, NW Ecuador in the Chocó-Darien eco region. Habitats consist of a mosaic of old-growth forests, pastures, cacao plantations as well as regenerating forests.
Moths were sampled quantitively in a using traditional funnel traps, equipped with a LepiLED Mini switch from Insects & Light, Jena, Germany. A catch started at dusk at around 18:00 and lasted 12 hours.
Sampling took place simultaneously in two strata:
| Stratum | Height above ground |
|---|---|
| understory | 1.7 m |
| canopy | 12.4 – 20.9 m |
We conducted surveys in four habitat types:
| Abbreviation | Habitat type |
|---|---|
| CR | cacao regeneration |
| OG-high | old growth forest at high elevations |
| OG-low | old growth forest at low elevations |
| PR | pasture regeneration |
We sampled two plots of each habitat type three times (2x in 2021, 1x in 2022), which resulted in a total of 48 Samples:
2 Strata x 4 Habitat types x 2 plots x 3 sampling events.
Plots were equipped with environmental sensors (iButton hygrochrons, model #DS1923, Maxim Integrated Products) in April 2022. The loggers recorded temperature and humidity every 15 minutes from April 2022 to December 2022, April 2023 – June 2023 and from September 2023 – October 2023.
Species determination and species number assignment
We focussed on a total of five taxonomically well known and ecology interesting groups of moths (Insecta: Lepiodptera): Erebidae-Arctiinae, Geometridae, Saturniidae, Sphingidae and Hedylidae. The dataset compromises a total of 12,472 individuals of 676 species collected in 48 samples.
Species were identified to the lowest possible taxonomic level usinff reference collections from G. Brehm, Phyletisches Museum Jena (PMJ), Germany and the Natural History Museum, London, England and other sources. DNA barcoding data further improved these assignments. Species numbers are cross-comparable to individuals housed in the PMJ from other campaigns in the Neotropical region collected by G.Brehm since 1999 (Ecaudor, Costa Rica, Peru).
Catalogues with species numbers for the focaltaxa of this study are partly available:
| Family | Reference |
|---|---|
| Arctiinae | Brehm et al., 2025 |
| Geometridae | tba |
| Saturniidae | tba |
| Sphingidae | tba |
| Hedylidae | tba |
Note: These species numbers are unique within a family, but not across families.
Results
Average species richness was higher in the understory (73.54 ± 22.58) than in the canopy (59.09 ± 17.24), and median sample sizes were similar (understory: 217.5 (160.5 – 336), canopy: 187.5 (138 – 328.5)). We found taxon-specific patterns: Arctiinae and Sphingidae – the stronger flyers – were more species-rich and abundant in the canopy, and weaker flyers Geometridae and Saturniidae were more species-rich and abundant in the understory.
Datafiles
- Moth_comm_more_diverse_in_understory than_canopy_tropical_lowland rainforest_nw_Ecuador__Individuals.csv
- Raw data of each individual moth sampled in the surveys including Taxanomic data and details on sampling sites.
- Moth_comm_more_diverse_in_understory than_canopy_tropical_lowland rainforest_nw_Ecuador__Species.csv
- Compiled species list including German common names, endangerment status, and reference library species number.
Descriptions
All individual specimens sampled in 48 samples are listed in Moth_comm_more_diverse_in_understory than_canopy_tropical_lowland rainforest_nw_Ecuador__Individuals with all information on sampling event and taxonomy. Furthermore, we provide corresponding availbale environmental data
All species handled in this survey are listed under Moth_comm_more_diverse_in_understory than_canopy_tropical_lowland rainforest_nw_Ecuador__Species with specific notes on taxonomic level of determination
Moth_comm_more_diverse_in_understory_than_canopy_tropical_lowland_rainforest_nw_Ecuador__Individuals.csv
- RNr: running number; display dataset in a standardized way with ascending Sample_Ids.
- Note: There are gaps for specimens collected on field campaigns that do not belong to this study
- Sample_ID: unique code for individual moths
- Species_Nr_Families: combination of the species catalogue number + family, important for discriminating species numbers across taxa
- species number: number of each species in the catalogues for each family. See species determination and species number assignment for details
- Family: currently valid taxonomic information for family level
- Subfamily: currently valid taxonomic information for subfamily level - only Erebidae-Arctiinae and within Geometridae
- Tribe: currently valid taxonomic information for tribe level - only within Arctiinae
- genus: currently valid taxonomic information for genus level
- species: information on species complexes. Individuals that could be determined to species level in one trap type but only to a complex in the other are assigned to a species complex for analyses
- Taxon_analyses: analyses of species composition are based on different taxonomic leves. For that, Tribes of Arctiinae, Subfamillies of Geometridae and the families Hedylidae, Saturniidae and Sphingidae are on the same level
- BIN: barcode Index Number in Bold System
- COI-5P Seq. Length: length of the analysed DNA part
- Sex: male or female
- Samplecode: identifier of each sample
- Stratum: canopy or understory
- Canopy_height: meters above the ground, this indicates the height of the trap, not the canopy itself
- Plot: plot scheme used by REASSEMBLY project
- Plottype: treatment of plots
- Plotnumber: plot scheme used by REASSEMBLY project
- Regeneration_since: year of purchase and start of regeneration of areas owned by Fundacion Jocotoco, no old growth forests and active sites included
- Elevation_plot: meters above sea level
- Date: starting date of each sampling event
- Average_Temp [°C]: mean temperature of the plots
- Average_Hum [%]: mean humidity of the plots
- discarded_Individuals_pictures: Specimens sampled but deposited in the collection were photographed.
Moth_comm_more_diverse_in_understory_than_canopy_tropical_lowland_rainforest_nw_Ecuador__Species.csv
- Family: currently valid taxonomic information for family level
- species number: number of each species in the catalogues for each family. See species determination and species number assignment for details
- Species_Nr_Families: combination of the species catalogue number + family, important for discriminating species numbers across taxa
- Taxon_analyses: analyses of species composition are based on different taxonomic leves. For that, tribes of Arctiinae, subfamillies of Geometridae and the families Hedylidae, Saturniidae and Sphingidae are on the same level
- genus: currently valid taxonomic information for genus level Names include notes:
- gen.: genus of the specimen could not be assigned
- species: currently valid taxonomic information for species level. Names include notes:
- sp.: species of the specimen could not be assigned
- nr: specimen closely related the given species name
- ?: determniation is not completely clear
- gr: specimen belonging to a species complex
- NN: specimen to be determined
- check: specimen name with pending validation
