Data from: Antagonistic effects of light pollution and warming on habitat-forming seaweeds
Data files
Jun 17, 2026 version files 4.05 MB
-
10198052.csv
103.40 KB
-
10198055.csv
96.97 KB
-
10198058.csv
97.38 KB
-
10237444.csv
97.15 KB
-
10505453.csv
96.98 KB
-
10505456.csv
97.13 KB
-
10620182.csv
97.11 KB
-
10620255.csv
97.09 KB
-
10979703.csv
97.24 KB
-
20027925.csv
96.86 KB
-
20027927.csv
97.24 KB
-
20043395.csv
96.98 KB
-
20043397.csv
96.50 KB
-
20043398.csv
97.19 KB
-
20046835.csv
97.35 KB
-
20056142.csv
96.97 KB
-
20056143.csv
97.21 KB
-
20056145.csv
63.95 KB
-
20056156.csv
97.06 KB
-
20061290.csv
97.22 KB
-
20061291.csv
97.03 KB
-
20061292.csv
96.99 KB
-
20061294.csv
96.94 KB
-
20061295.csv
96.79 KB
-
20061296.csv
97.17 KB
-
20061297.csv
97.07 KB
-
20061298.csv
97.10 KB
-
20061299.csv
97.07 KB
-
20061300.csv
97.21 KB
-
20061301.csv
96.67 KB
-
20061302.csv
97.17 KB
-
20061304.csv
97.16 KB
-
20061305.csv
97.25 KB
-
20061306.csv
97.20 KB
-
20061307.csv
97.01 KB
-
20065890.csv
97.13 KB
-
20065891.csv
96.76 KB
-
20065893.csv
96.83 KB
-
20065895.csv
97.27 KB
-
20065902.csv
97.12 KB
-
ALAN_Seaweed_Analysis_MC_140824.Rmd
85.41 KB
-
Incubation_Data_v2.csv
6.92 KB
-
README.md
12.97 KB
-
Seaweed_Data_Growth_140824.csv
83.96 KB
-
Survival_Data.csv
9.11 KB
Abstract
Artificial Light at Night (ALAN) is an emerging global stressor that is likely to interact with other stressors such as warming, affecting habitat-forming species and ecological functions. Seaweeds are dominant habitat-forming species in temperate marine ecosystems, where they support primary productivity and diverse ecological communities. Warming is a major stressor affecting seaweed forests, but the effects of ALAN on seaweeds are largely unknown. We manipulated ALAN (0 lx vs. 25 lx at night) and temperature (ambient vs. +1.54°C warming) to test their independent and interactive effects on the survival, growth (biomass, total‐, blade‐ and stipe‐length), and function (photosynthesis, primary productivity and respiration) on the juveniles of two habitat‐forming seaweeds, the kelp Ecklonia radiata and the fucoid Sargassum sp. Warming significantly increased Ecklonia mortality; however, ALAN did not affect mortality. ALAN had positive effects on Ecklonia biomass, total and blade growth rates, and gross primary productivity; however, warming largely counterbalanced these effects. We found no significant effects of warming or ALAN on Ecklonia photosynthetic yield, stipe length, net primary productivity, or respiration rates. We found no effects of ALAN or warming on Sargassum for any of the measured variables. Synthesis. Our findings indicate that ALAN can have positive effects on seaweed growth and functioning, but such effects are likely species‐specific and can be counterbalanced by warming, suggesting an antagonistic interaction between these global stressors. These findings can help us to predict and manage the effects of these stressors on seaweeds, which underpin coastal biodiversity.
https://doi.org/10.5061/dryad.wm37pvmws
This dataset contains data with calculations of growth rates, and data analysis files for an experiment that investigated independent and interactive effects of warming and artificial light at night on the survival, growth (biomass, total-, blade- and stipe-length) and function (photosynthesis, primary productivity, respiration) of two habitat-forming seaweeds, the kelp Ecklonia radiata and the fucoid Sargassum sp.
Description of the data and file structure
The .rmd file contains the code used for analysis and data visualisation. The datasets used in the analysis are the CSV files, with growth rates calculated as per the methods. Data are listed below in the order they appear in the R analysis file.
Dataset Overview
This dataset contains environmental and biological data collected to assess the effects of artificial light at night (ALAN) and warming on Sargassum and Ecklonia microbial communities, productivity, and respiration. The dataset includes temperature and light measurements from HOBO loggers, as well as incubation and seaweed growth data.
File Descriptions
Experimental Metadata/Original datasets
Seaweed_Data_Growth_140824.csv: Data on seaweed growth rates.- Data is in long format, with each row representing a single seaweed individual at a single point in time. Tanks had three tagged individuals of either seaweed species (Sargassum or Ecklonia), labelled individual A, B, and C. Therefore, each tank and week has three rows for each individual. Measurements were repeated over time in additional rows. Variables are as below:
- Tank: Individual tank number, labelled 1 through to 40. Tanks contained three individuals of each seaweed species (Sargassum and Ecklonia), labelled individual A, B, and C.
- Light: Light treatment, either ALAN (Artificial Light at night) or dark (dark at night). All tanks were lit during the daylight hours.
- Warming: Warming treatment, either ambient (ambient flow-through seawater conditions from Sydney Harbour at the time of the experiment) or Warm (+1.5C above ambient).
- Species: Identity of seaweed species in tank, either Sargassum sp. or Ecklonia radiata.
- Week: Week of the experiment in which measurements were taken (0, 1, 2, 4). Week 0 represents the start of the experiment, while week 1 represents after 1 week of exposure to the respective treatments.
- Hobo.logger: Serial number of HOBO logger used in the tank. to record the temperature during the experiment.
- Initial_No: Initial number of seaweed individuals per tank. Each tank had several individuals to mimic natural conditions; however, only three were tagged for measurement, and individuals were not replaced over the experiment.
- Mortality: Number of individuals that died that week in that tank
- Individual: Tagged Individual A, B, or C in each tank
- Biomass: Wet weight of seaweed individual in grams
- Biomass Change: Simple rate of change in biomass from week to week, calculated using the following formula = X2-X1/X1, where X1 is biomass in the previous week, and X2 is biomass in the current week. Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Relative Biomass Growth: Relative biomass growth rate from week to week. Calculated using the following formula = (((X2/X1)^(1/7))-1)*100, where X1 is biomass in the previous week and X2 is biomass in the current week, and 7 is the number of days (1 week). Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Total.Length: Length of seaweed in mm
- Length.Change: Simple rate of change in length from week to week, calculated using the following formula = X2-X1/X1, where X1 is the length in the previous week, and X2 is the length in the current week. Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Relative.Vertical.Growth: Relative change in total length from week to week. Calculated using the following formula = (((X2/X1)^(1/7))-1)*100, where X1 is the length in the previous week and X2 is the length in the current week, and 7 is the number of days (1 week). Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Stipe.Length: Stipe length in mm (Ecklonia only). Values are NA for Sargassum as due to different morphology, stipe, and blade length were not measured for Sargassum.
- Stipe.Change: Simple rate of change in stipe length from week to week, calculated using the following formula = X2-X1/X1, where X1 is stipe length in the previous week, and X2 is stipe length in the current week. Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Relative.Stipe.Growth: Relative change in stipe length from week to week. Calculated using the following formula = (((X2/X1)^(1/7))-1)*100, where X1 is the stipe length in the previous week and X2 is the stipe length in the current week, and 7 is the number of days (1 week). Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Blade.Length: Length of blade (Ecklonia only) in mm. Values are NA for Sargassum as due to different morphology, stipe, and blade length were not measured for Sargassum.
- Blade.Change: Simple rate of change in blade length from week to week, calculated using the following formula = X2-X1/X1, where X1 is blade length in the previous week, and X2 is length in the current week. Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Relative.Blade.Growth: Relative change in blade length from week to week. Calculated using the following formula = (((X2/X1)^(1/7))-1)*100, where X1 is blade length in the previous week and X2 is length in the current week, and 7 is the number of days (1 week). Values are NA in week 0, as this is the start of the experiment, so there is no rate of change.
- Attachment: Was individual seaweed attached to the rock at the time of measurement. Only assessed in weeks 3 and 4 of the experiment; therefore, values are NA for weeks 0-2. Values are NA when individuals were dead.
- Pam1: Measures of maximum photosynthetic yield measured with a Pulse Amplitude Modulated (PAM) fluorometer. This was repeated 3 times, in 3 different spots on each seaweed individual at each measurement point (Pam1A, Pam2A, Pam3A, etc.) These were then averaged to give
- PAM_Average: Average of three PAM (Pulse Amplitude Modulated) fluorometer measurements taken per individual.
- Data is in long format, with each row representing a single seaweed individual at a single point in time. Tanks had three tagged individuals of either seaweed species (Sargassum or Ecklonia), labelled individual A, B, and C. Therefore, each tank and week has three rows for each individual. Measurements were repeated over time in additional rows. Variables are as below:
- Survival_Data.csv: Used for survival graphs and analysis.
- Tank: Individual tank number, labelled 1 through to 40. Tanks contained three individuals of each seaweed species (Sargassum and Ecklonia), labelled individual A, B, and C.
- Light: Light treatment, either ALAN (Artificial Light at night) or dark (dark at night). All tanks were lit during the daylight hours.
- Warming: Warming treatment, either ambient (ambient flowthrough seawater conditions from Sydney Harbour at the time of the experiment) or Warm (+1.5C above ambient).
- Species: Identity of seaweed species in tank, either Sargassum sp. or Ecklonia radiata.
- Week: Week of the experiment in which measurements were taken (0, 1, 2, 4). Week 0 represents the start of the experiment, while week 1 represents after 1 week of exposure to the respective treatments.
- Initial_No: Initial number of seaweed individuals per tank. Each tank had several individuals to mimic natural conditions; however, only three were tagged for measurement, and individuals were not replaced over the experiment.
- Mortality: Number of individuals that died that week in that tank
- Survival: Proportion (%) of surviving individuals in each tank during each week, calculated using the formula =100 - Mortality/Initial_No*100.
- Incubation_Data_v2.csv Used for Gross Primary Productivity (GPP), Respiration (R), and Net Primary productivity (NPP) graphs and analysis.
- Tank: Individual tank number, labelled 1 through to 40. Tanks contained three individuals of each seaweed species (Sargassum and Ecklonia), labelled individual A, B, and C.
- Light: Light treatment, either ALAN (Artificial Light at night) or dark (dark at night). All tanks were lit during the daylight hours.
- Warming: Warming treatment, either ambient (ambient flowthrough seawater conditions from Sydney Harbour at the time of the experiment) or Warm (+1.5C above ambient).
- Species: Identity of seaweed species in tank, either Sargassum sp. or Ecklonia radiata.
- Week: Week of the experiment in which measurements were taken (0, 1, 2, 4). Week 0 represents the start of the experiment, while week 1 represents after 1 week of exposure to the respective treatments.
- Swabbed individual: Record of which tagged individual was swabbed for microbial community assessment at the end of the experiment (n = 3-5, depending on the number of individuals surviving in each treatment). Only one individual per tank was swabbed.
- Incubated individual: Record of which tagged individual was used in incubations conducted at the end of the experiment (subsetted from swabbed individuals). Only one individual per tank was incubated.
- Incubation date: Date of incubation, as incubations were conducted over two days for each species.
- Logger.number: MiniDOT logger number corresponding to each incubation, used to measure dissolved oxygen.
- Light.start.time: Start time of "light" incubation.
- Light.end.time: End time of "light incubation.
- dark.start.time: Start time of "dark" incubation.
- Day.Raw.mg.l.hour: Raw oxygen measurements during "light" incubations
- Night.Raw.mg.l.hour: Raw oxygen measurements during "dark" incubations
- Chamber.Volume.m3: volume of incubation chamber in m3 (constant value of 0.002 m3)
- Chamber.Litres: volume of the incubation chamber in litres (constant value of 2 litres).
- Seaweed.weight: Biomass of seaweed in grams at time of incubation.
- Convert_to_umol: Constant value 32 for conversion of oxygen from mg to umol.
- Seconds: Constant value of 3600, representing incubation time in seconds.
- NPP: Net primary Productivity, calculated using the following formula =(((Day_Raw_Value*Volume_litres)/1000)/32/Seaweed_Weight)*1000000
- CR: Respiration, calculated using the following formula = (((Night_Raw_Value*Volume_litres)/1000)/32/Seaweed_Weight)*1000000
- GPP: Gross Primary Productivity, calculated as NPP - CR.
- HOBO Logger data files: 10198058.csv, 10198055.csv, 10198052.csv, 10237444.csv, 10505453.csv, 10505456.csv, 10620182.csv, 10620255.csv, 10979703.csv, 20027925.csv, 20027927.csv, 20043395.csv, 20043397.csv, 20043398.csv, 20046835.csv, 20056142.csv, 20056143.csv, 20056145.csv, 20056156.csv, 20061290.csv, 20061291.csv, 20061292.csv, 20061294.csv, 20061295.csv, 20061296.csv, 20061297.csv, 20061298.csv, 20061299.csv, 20061300.csv, 20061301.csv, 20061302.csv, 20061304.csv, 20061305.csv, 20061306.csv, 20061307.csv, 20065890.csv, 20065891.csv, 20065893.csv, 20065895.csv, 20065902.csv, 10198058.csv
- All HOBO logger data files are named with the serial number of the HOBO logger, and contain temperature data corresponding to the tank with the HOBO logger serial number listed against it. All these data files have identical variables:
- Date Time, GMT+10:00: Date and time in GMT+10:00:
- Temp, °C (LGR S/N: 10198055, SEN S/N: 10198055, LBL: Temperature): Temperature in °C
- Intensity, Lux (LGR S/N: 10198055, SEN S/N: 10198055, LBL: Light): Light intensity in Lux
- Coupler Attached (LGR S/N: 10198055): Cell says "Logged" at the time when the coupler was attached. Other cells empty.
- Host Connected (LGR S/N: 10198055): Cell says "Logged" at the time when the host was connected. Other cells empty.
- Stopped (LGR S/N: 10198055): Cell says "Logged" at the time when the logger was stopped. Other cells empty.
- End Of File (LGR S/N: 10198055): Cell says "Logged" at the time when the file ends. Other cells empty.
Analysis Scripts
ALAN_Seaweed_Analysis_MC_140824.Rmd: R Markdown file containing the analysis workflow for the dataset, including statistical tests and data visualization.
Data Format and Accessibility
- Most environmental data are in
.csvformat and can be accessed with standard data processing tools.
Collections and treatments
We collected 102 Ecklonia radiata juveniles and 151 Sargassum juveniles from a naturally dark (i.e., low ALAN exposure) rocky shore in Chowder Bay, Sydney Harbour, Australia (33°50'26.1"S, 151°15'09.6"E) in September 2023 (austral spring) and transported them to the nearby (< 500 m) Sydney Institute of Marine Science (SIMS). Seaweed was collected under an s37 Research Permit (no. FP23/6) issued by DPI, NSW. Ecklonia juveniles (mean length 144.36 mm, 4.27 SE) were defined as stage 1 early sporophytes with a single main blade and no lateral laminae (Fig. S1) (Kirkman 1984). Juvenile Sargassum sp. were defined as small Sargassum sp. < 200 mm (mean length 81.74 mm 2.45 SE) (Straub et al. 2022) (Figure S1). Because of their high morphological and species diversity, Sargassum is difficult to distinguish to the species level without detailed microscopic examination (Coleman and Wernberg 2017), and so we just use the genus name here. We used juveniles as they are a foundational life stage for seaweed populations, making their vulnerability to stressors important to understand because of implications for recruitment and recovery from disturbances. Their smaller size also allowed us to incorporate whole individuals into our mesocosms.
Individual seaweeds were randomly distributed across tanks within 4 hours of collection. Each individual was carefully attached to small rocks (30 – 50 mm decorative pebbles) using elastic bands (Figure S2)(Gonzalez et al. 2024). Ecklonia tanks contained 5 – 6 individuals while Sargassum tanks contained 7 – 8 individuals. Tanks used were 45 L, so differences in the number of individuals per tank was assumed to have negligible effects. Seaweeds were acclimatised for one week at ambient seawater temperatures (Straub et al. 2022). All tanks were lit at ~ 3000 lx during the day with cool white light (6500K 150 cm LED tubes from MakeMyLED). This is within the range of daily lux levels naturally experienced by kelp (Bearham et al. 2013) and is equivalent to natural daylight levels measured under cloudy conditions at 1 m depth in Chowder Bay, using an underwater lux meter (SpectroSense2; Skye, Wales). After acclimation, tanks were randomly allocated to one of four treatments: ALAN/warm, ALAN/ambient, dark/warm or dark/ambient (n = 5 tanks). Dark tanks were assigned to a 12 h light (~ 3000 lx) and 12 h dark (0 lx) cycle. ALAN treatments had 12 h of light (~ 3000 lx) during the day, and 12 h of dim light during the night (25 lx). This intensity is similar to what has been detected in urban marine systems (Davies et al. 2015) and to what has been used in similar studies (Davies et al. 2015, Maggi and Benedetti-Cecchi 2018, Bauer et al. 2022). Warm treatments were heated to a target temperature of 2 C above ambient seawater conditions as projected under the RCP 4.5 emission stabilisation scenario (Thomson et al. 2011) using 300-watt bar heaters (Thermocontrol 300; EHEIM, Germany), while the rest were unmanipulated (ambient seawater conditions). Temperatures were allowed to fluctuate according to daily ambient seawater temperatures to reflect natural temperature variability (Figure S3). HOBO Pendant Loggers (Onset, USA) measured temperature at 30-minute intervals for the entire experiment. Mean temperature was 18.92 0.002 oC in ambient treatments and 20.46 0.003 oC in warm treatments over the experiment (mean difference of +1.54 oC; Figure S3).
Survival and biomass change
Within each tank, three individual seaweeds were randomly tagged for measurement. A two-factor ANOVA confirmed there was no significant difference in size of tagged individuals among treatments at the start of the experiment (Table S1, p > 0.5 for all variables). Survival was recorded weekly, as % of surviving of all individuals within a tank (tagged and untagged). Seaweeds were characterised as ‘dead’ when the specimen lost its structural integrity, i.e., the stipe was fully detached from the blade, or the blade tissue was fully degraded (Straub et al. 2022). We also measured biomass, length and photosynthetic efficiency weekly for tagged individuals. Seaweeds were blotted dry and weighed using scales to measure biomass as total wet weight, to 0.01 g. For Ecklonia, we measured total length (base of stipe to the top of the central blade), blade length (top of stipe to top of the central blade), and stipe length (base of stipe to base of blade). For Sargassum, the total length was measured as the distance from the base of the stipe (above the holdfast) to the top of the longest blade. We did not measure blade length and stipe length of Sargassum due to its variable morphology. We calculated relative growth rate (‘change’) of biomass, total length, blade length, and stipe length as the proportional increase in biomass or length per week, using the following equation:
Relative Growth Rate (% day-1)
Where Wi = initial wet weight (g), total length, blade length or stipe length (mm) at the start of the experiment, Wt1 = wet weight (g) and total length, blade length or stipe length (mm) at the respective measurement week, and t = days passed in treatment, as per Straub et al. (2022). This formula has been determined to be the most accurate for calculating seaweed growth rates (Yong et al. 2013). Change could be positive (due to growth) or negative (due to loss of tissue).
Seaweed functioning
Photosynthetic efficiency (maximum quantum yield) was measured weekly using a pulse-amplitude modulated fluorometer (Diving-PAM; WALZ, Germany). Whole individual seaweeds were wrapped in foil and dark-acclimated for 10 minutes prior to measurement (Mayer-Pinto et al. 2015). Three replicate measures were taken for each individual seaweed (on a single blade for Ecklonia and on separate blades for Sargassum), to improve precision. These replicate measures were then averaged per individual. Respiration rates (R), Gross Primary Productivity (GPP), and Net Primary Productivity (NPP) were measured at the end of the experiment (after 4 weeks) for n = 6 individuals, selected randomly, from each treatment and species. To achieve an appropriate replication level, in some cases, two individuals (maximum) were collected from the same tank. Tank was included as a factor in models to account for potential non-independence (see below). Oxygen flux rates were measured under ‘light’ and ‘dark’ conditions, with seaweeds incubated within their tanks, in clear plastic 2 L containers containing miniDOT® loggers (White and Davoult 2022). In ‘dark’ incubations, dark treatments were kept completely dark while ALAN treatments were illuminated with artificial light (25 lux). Productivity and respiration of seaweeds were assessed under their respective temperature and light treatments to assess functioning as it would occur under stressor conditions(Gonzalez et al. 2024). Incubations were done at the same time of day for all replicates, and over two days for each species (date was included in models to control for this, see below). Respiration (dark) and NPP (light) raw rates were standardised by chamber volume and seaweed wet weight (gWW) to give values as O2/mg/L/m3/gWW, to control for differences in seaweed size between treatments at the end of the experiment. GPP was calculated as NPP – R (gross primary productivity in the absence of respiration).
Statistical analysis
Data were analysed separately for each species and response variable in R (R Core Team 2022). Linear mixed-effect models were fitted using the ‘lmer’ function from the ‘lme4’ package (Bates et al. 2014). For repeated measures (biomass growth, vertical growth, stipe growth, blade growth and photosynthetic yield), we treated light (two levels, ALAN and dark) and warming (two levels, ambient and warming) as interactive fixed factors, with time as a covariate, and individual replicates (ID) nested in tank as a random factor to account for repeated measures of the same individuals. In all models, time (week) was treated as numeric, as responses were expected to vary linearly through time. For models testing effects on gross primary productivity (GPP), net primary productivity (NPP), and respiration (R), we had the same factors as above, except time (since measurements were only taken once, at the end of the experiment), and with date as a random factor, as incubations were done over two days per species. Skewed data were cube-root transformed before analysis to meet assumptions due to negative values. Gaussian distribution was determined to be the most appropriate distribution for all models. Significance was assessed using a likelihood-ratio test via the ‘Anova’ function (type II) from the ‘car’ package (Fox et al. 2012). Pairwise post hoc tests were performed using emmeans for interactions involving only categorical variables (Lenth 2023). Where significant interactions involved an interaction with time, emtrends was used to test for difference in slopes between treatments and to test for significant differences between treatments at each week (0, 1, 2, 3, 4) (Lenth 2023).
