Data from: Long-fuse evolution of carnivoran skeletal phenomes through the Cenozoic
Data files
Oct 28, 2025 version files 388.86 KB
-
extant_data_250205.csv
201.03 KB
-
extinct_data_250215.csv
178.12 KB
-
README.md
3.07 KB
-
tree_prune_final_2502015.tre
6.63 KB
Abstract
Climatic change is hypothesized to promote phenotypic diversification. While neontological analyses are often used to test this hypothesis, extant data only capture time-averaged signals of surviving lineages. More nuanced tests require paired and longitudinal climatic and organismal data. Here, we developed the most comprehensive phenomic dataset of pan-carnivorans to test hypotheses that Cenozoic climatic change influenced the evolution of the cranial, appendicular, and axial skeleton. We found support that a hierarchical progression of ecological diversification across the Cenozoic significantly influenced the establishment of modern carnivorans. Specifically, extinctions during the Eocene-Oligocene Transition released crown carnivorans from a constrained adaptive zone to interfamilial skeletal diversification. Intrafamilial skeletal diversification did not occur for another 20 million years until after the Mid-Miocene Climate Transition. Our work demonstrates the essential role of macroevolutionary data from the fossil record for revealing how major global climatic events steered the evolutionary trajectories of modern skeletal phenomes.
Dataset DOI: 10.5061/dryad.z8w9ghxrz
Description of the data and file structure
tree_prune_final_2502015.tre contains the pruned phylogeny
extant_data_250205.csv and extinct_data_250215.csv contain raw trait data. All traits measured in mm. Empty cells indicate that trait could not be measured.
Clade = clade association for each specimen. Either Carnivora, Carnivoramorpha, or Pan-carnivora (Hyaenodonta or Oxyaenodonta)
Family = the family in which the specimen is a part of
Species = specimen's species name
Status = whether the specimen is extinct or extant
Catalog = museum catalog number for each specimen
Geomean = geometric mean of all traits
Cranial traits
CBL = condylobasal length
POC = postorbital constriction breadth
ZB = zygomatic breadth
MB = mastoid breadth
AFH = anterior facial height
PFH = posterior facial height
CVH = cranial vault height
PW = palate width
BCL = basicranial length
cran_MRL = molar row length
cran_M1L = first molar length
cran_M1W = first molar width
mandibular traits
MAT = moment arm of temporalis
MAM = moment arm of masseter
MAM2 = moment arm of masseter
MOL = molar out-lever
COL = canine out-lever
MW = mandibular width
AMW = anterior mandibular width
man_MRL = molar row length
man_M1L = first molar length
man_M1W = first molar width
vertebral traits
C3 = third cervical vertebrae; C5 = fifth cervical vertebrae; T1 = first thoracic vertebrae; midT = middle thoracic vertebrae; diaT = diaphragmatic thoracic vertebrae; lastT = last thoracic vertebrae; L1 = first lumbar vertebrae; midL = middle lumbar vertebrae; lastL = last lumbar vertebrae
VW = vertebral width
VH = vertebral height
CL = centrum length
CW = centrum width (posterior)
CH = centrum height (posterior)
ZL = inter-zygapophyseal length
LW = mid-lamina width
NSH = neural spine height
TPDV = transverse process/diapophysis dorsoventral angle
PZA = pre-zygapophysis joint angle
NSA = neural spine angle
TPAP = transverse process/diapophysis anteroposterior angle
sacral_L = sacral length
sacral_H = sacral height
sacral_W = sacral width
scap_L = scapula length
scap_W = scapula width
hum_L = humerus length
hum_D = humerus mid-shaft width
hum_prox = humerus proximal width
hum_dist = humerus distal width
ul_L = ulna length
ul_D = ulna mid-shaft width
ul_OL = ulnar olecranon length
rad_L = radius length
rad_D = radius mid-shaft width
MC3L = 3rd metacarpel length
MC3W = 3rd metacarpel width
PPL = Manus proximal phalanx length
PPW = Manus proximal phalanx width
pel_L = pelvis length
fem_L = femur length
fem_D = Femur mid-shaft width
fem_EB = Femur distal width
fem_GT = Height of the greater trochanter of the femur
tib_L = tibia length
tib_D = tibia mid-shaft width
tib_prox = tibia proximal width
tib_dist = tibia distal width
fib_L = fibula length
cal_L = Calcaneus length
MT3L = 3rd metatarsal length
MT3D = 3rd metatarsal width
