Phenotypic homogenization and potential fitness constraints following non-native introgression in an endemic sportfish
Data files
Oct 17, 2024 version files 72.90 KB
-
genotype_data.xlsx
27.38 KB
-
metadata.xlsx
18.26 KB
-
phenotype_data.xlsx
21.73 KB
-
README.md
5.54 KB
Oct 23, 2024 version files 200 MB
-
genotype_data.csv
17.29 KB
-
genotype_data.xlsx
27.38 KB
-
metadata.csv
10.12 KB
-
metadata.xlsx
18.26 KB
-
otolith_images.zip
199.89 MB
-
phenotype_data.csv
10.90 KB
-
phenotype_data.xlsx
21.73 KB
-
README.md
6.38 KB
Abstract
Introgressive hybridization may lead to contrasting evolutionary outcomes that are difficult to predict, since they depend on the fitness effects of endogenous genomic interactions and environmental factors. Conservation of endemic biodiversity may be more effective with direct measurement of introgressed ancestry and fitness in wild populations, especially for keystone taxa at risk of hybridization following species introductions. We assessed the relationship of non-native ancestry with growth and body condition in the basin-restricted Neosho Bass (Micropterus velox; NB), focusing on two streams in the NB native range that are admixed extensively with non-native Smallmouth Bass (M. dolomieu; SMB). We quantified genetic composition of 116 fish from Big Sugar Creek (N=46) and Elk River (N=70) at 14 microsatellite loci. Using back-calculated total length-at-age estimated from sagittal otoliths, we assessed whether genetic ancestry explained variation in von Bertalanffy growth model parameters, accounting for sex and stream effects. We then assessed the relationship of ancestry and body condition. We found no differences in growth parameters by sex, stream, or ancestry, suggesting phenotypic homogenization which could be mediated by selection on body size. We found a negative correlation between SMB ancestry and condition, including lower condition in Big Sugar Creek, possibly reflecting a trade-off between maximum length and condition with respect to overall fitness. We show that ongoing non-native introgression, which may be augmented by anthropogenic SMB introductions, may attenuate evolutionary differentiation between species and directly influence fitness, possibly having critical implications for long-term persistence and management of adaptive potential in a popular and ecologically important endemic sportfish.
Below, you will find all data included in Gunn et al. (2024). These data can be used along with the associated project GitHub repository to work through all data analyses step-by-step.
Project: Effects of admixture on fitness in Neosho Bass populations
We assessed the effect of admixture on fitness in two stream populations within the native range of the Neosho Bass (M. velox; NB) which are known to have extensively hybridized with Smallmouth Bass (Micropterus dolomieu; SMB). Specifically, we used 14 microsatellite loci in a Bayesian analysis of population structure to estimate proportions of interspecific ancestry in individuals collected from Big Sugar Creek and the Elk River in southwestern Missouri (Central Interior Highlands ecoregion (CIH), North America). We used ancestry inference to estimate the proportion of ancestry derived from SMB and NB. For each individual, we measured age and total length and projected individual growth using the standard parameterization of the von Bertalanffy growth model. Finally, we used body condition as a proxy for fitness and generated an ancestry-condition correlation across the global dataset. We ultimately sought to understand the short-term genetic consequences of admixture for NB populations in order to better inform management and long-term viability of distinct, economically and ecologically important sportfish species in the CIH.
Data
In this repository, you will find three separate data files (each file is provided both in comma separate value format, i.e., .csv, and Excel format, i.e., .xlsx). Files in .csv format are provided for machine readability, but all corresponding code requires files in .xlsx format for analysis. We also provide one data folder. Files and folders are required to reproduce analyses for Gunn et al. (2024):
- raw genotype data (genotype_data.csv; genotype_data.xlsx)
- raw phenotype data (phenotype_data.csv; phenotype_data.xlsx)
- metadata (metadata.csv; metadata.xlsx)
- raw otolith images (otolith_images.zip)
Below, we provide a full description of each data file and folder, including names and descriptions of variables in each column.
genotype_data.csv (.xlsx)
- "sample_id": a unique, alphanumeric ID for each sample
- "structure_number": the alphanumerical ID for each individual in the proper format for analysis with the program STRUCTURE
- *locus**names: for each microsatellite locus used in this study, there are two adjacent columns, the first labeled with the locus name (e.g., "mdo9", "mdo5", "mdo7", "*mdo10", etc.) and the second with no header label (blank). Each column contains one of two alleles at that locus (three-digit numerical value, e.g., 146). *Note: columns with blank headers must remain blank, as they will be read and transformed using the R library employed for analysis of these data.
phenotype_data.csv (.xlsx)
- "sample_id": same as in metadata and genotype data (followed by "structure_number"; see Analysis 3, Phase 1, step 1e)
- "sex": male or female, determined by internal gonad examination,
- "tl_alive": total length (mm) of the fish immediately upon capture by rod-and-reel, as measured from the tip of the lower mandible to the posterior tip of the caudal fin squeezed together
- "tl_dead": total length (mm) of the fish upon sample processeing (after approximately one month frozen)
- "mass_dead": mass (g) of the fish in grams at time of sample processing
- "meas_ints": initials of the person doing the phenotypic measuring, measuring, or assessment, for later analysis of observer/measurement bias
- "eddie_age": age estimate based on sagittal otolith annuli, performed by Eddie Sterling
- "joe_age": age estimate performed by Joe Gunn
- "michael_age": age estimate performed by Michael Moore
- "consensus_age": ultimate age estimate based on consensus of three agers, Eddie, Joe, and Michael
- "sl": standard length (mm) of the fish, as measured from the tip of the mandible to the hyperal plate, just anterior to the caudal fin
- "bd": body depth (mm) , as measured at the thickest part of the fish
- "hl": head length (mm), as measured from the tip of the lower mandible to the posterior end of the gill plate
- "ol": orbital length (mm) , the diameter of the eye ball
- "sd_ray": the number of soft dorsal fin rays.
metadata.csv (.xlsx)
- "sample_id": a unique, alphanumeric ID for each sample
- "river_code": the alphabetical prefix for each sample id, where "FBS" stands for "Fitness, Big Sugar Creek" and "FER" stands for "Fitness, Elk River"
- "sample_number": the numerical prefix for each sample (01, 02, 03,..., 71)
- "structure_number": the alphanumerical ID for each individual in the proper format for analysis with the program STRUCTURE
- "easting": easting UTM (ZONE 15S) measurement (GIS)
- "northing": northing UTM (ZONE 15S) measurement (GIS)
- "dist_from_df": distance (m) from Deep Ford Access (DFA) at which each sample was collected
- "range_id": species native range from which each individual was collected
- "river": river or stream from which each individual was collected
- "population": designation for whether the sample was included in growth analyses ("sample") or was used solely as a reference for ancestry analysis ("reference")
NA - not available
otolith_images.zip
Compressed (zip) folder containing all raw otolith images (PNG) analyzed in this study. Images are labeled as described for the "sample*id" column of each raw dataset (genotype_data phenotypes_data, metadata), i.e., with a unique alphanumeric ID representing the fish from which the otolith was collected.
To reproduce analyses for Gunn et al. (2020), follow instructions in the README.md file on the project Zenodo repository (https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.13983316). First, download these data into your /raw_data directory within the home working directory. You should then be ready to fully analyze data as described in the associated Rmarkdown files.
If you have any questions or issues with data and/or code, please don't hesitate to contact me: jcgunn@uvm.edu
Versioning
Oct 23, V2: Added image folder and csv versions of all Excel files
Fish were collected by hook-and-line angling. Tissue samples (~25mg) for genetic analysis were removed from the upper caudal fin and stored in 95% ethanol until processing. All phenotypic measurements were obtained as described in the final publication.
